20 must-read fantasy books like The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) by Sarah Painter

Cover of The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) by Sarah Painter

The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

By: Sarah Painter

4.43

Format: 292 pages, Kindle Edition

Mysterious, magical, and a little bit deadly... Welcome to Unholy Island. Luke Taylor was search…

If you liked the fantasy plot in The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) by Sarah Painter , here is a list of 20 books like this:

Cover of Boy of Chaotic Making (Whimbrel House, #3) by Charlie N. Holmberg

1. Boy of Chaotic Making (Whimbrel House, #3)

By: Charlie N. Holmberg

4.32

Format: 299 pages, Kindle Edition

A boy like no other embarks on a transformative journey of magic and self-discovery in the next enc… read more

Similar categories in Charlie N. Holmberg's Boy of Chaotic Making (Whimbrel House, #3) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • magic
  • fiction
Cover of Killing Time (The Time Police, #5) by Jodi Taylor

2. Killing Time (The Time Police, #5)

By: Jodi Taylor

4.56

Format: 461 pages, Kindle Edition

A ghost train, lost in Time, hurtles through the night... Two members of Team 236 are trapped on… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Taylor's Killing Time (The Time Police, #5) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • science fiction fantasy
  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • audiobook
Cover of Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1) by Rosalie Oaks

3. Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1)

By: Rosalie Oaks

4.13

Format: 367 pages, Kindle Edition

A Regency widow shouldn’t be hunting spectres all night. Lady Judith Avely’s magical gift for d… read more

Similar categories in Rosalie Oaks's Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
"Silence was often the best interrogation technique; something she had learned as a mother."

-Rosalie Oaks, Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1)

Cover of The Dead Letter Delivery (Glass Library, #4) by C.J. Archer

4. The Dead Letter Delivery (Glass Library, #4)

By: C.J. Archer

4.10

Format: 279 pages, Kindle Edition

The discovery of long-lost mail delivers a marriage proposal, a missing person, and a magical myste… read more

Similar categories in C.J. Archer's The Dead Letter Delivery (Glass Library, #4) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • magic
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of All Out of Leeds (DI Adams, #1) by Kim M. Watt

5. All Out of Leeds (DI Adams, #1)

By: Kim M. Watt

4.59

Format: 324 pages, Kindle Edition

Walk softly, and carry a very big stick … DI Adams fled London to escape bridge-dwelling monster… read more

Similar categories in Kim M. Watt's All Out of Leeds (DI Adams, #1) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) by Sarah Painter

6. The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

By: Sarah Painter

4.43

Format: 292 pages, Kindle Edition

Mysterious, magical, and a little bit deadly... Welcome to Unholy Island. Luke Taylor was search… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • science fiction fantasy
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of Storm Christopher (Frogmorton Farm #2.6) by Jodi Taylor

7. Storm Christopher (Frogmorton Farm #2.6)

By: Jodi Taylor

4.55

Format: 102 pages, Kindle Edition

A brand new Frogmorton Farm short story, from the bestselling author of the Chronicles of St Mary's… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Taylor's Storm Christopher (Frogmorton Farm #2.6) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • science fiction fantasy
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of The Book of Secrets (The Last Oracle, #1) by Melissa McShane

8. The Book of Secrets (The Last Oracle, #1)

By: Melissa McShane

4.09

Format: 192 pages, Paperback

Helena Davies just wants a job that will get her out of her parents’ basement. Abernathy’s Bookstor… read more

Similar categories in Melissa McShane's The Book of Secrets (The Last Oracle, #1) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • magic
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Three Ring Circus: A Fairy Story (The King's Watch Book 12) by Mark Hayden

9. Three Ring Circus: A Fairy Story (The King's Watch Book 12)

By: Mark Hayden

4.28

Format: 546 pages, Kindle Edition

What’s it like to live forever?Alicia is about to find out...Just because you don’t grow old, it do… read more

Similar categories in Mark Hayden's Three Ring Circus: A Fairy Story (The King's Watch Book 12) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • fantasy
Cover of Red & Dead (The Netherweird Chronicles, #1) by Violet Fenn

10. Red & Dead (The Netherweird Chronicles, #1)

By: Violet Fenn

4.17

Format: 327 pages, Kindle Edition

“Netherworld? Nether-f*cking-weird, more like.” Lili O’Reilly and her beloved cat, Grimm, live h… read more

Similar categories in Violet Fenn's Red & Dead (The Netherweird Chronicles, #1) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Dream Thief: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Five - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide by Violet Fenn

11. The Dream Thief: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Five - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide

By: Violet Fenn

4.55

Format: 257 pages, Kindle Edition

“There’s a corpse on my doorstep, a were-cat on my sofa and I’m being stalked by the assassins divi… read more

Similar categories in Violet Fenn's The Dream Thief: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Five - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

Cover of The High Gate  (The Netherweird Chronicles, #2) by Violet Fenn

12. The High Gate (The Netherweird Chronicles, #2)

By: Violet Fenn

4.43

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

“I’m being stalked by a vengeful half-witch, my love life’s deader than I am, and now there’s a run… read more

Similar categories in Violet Fenn's The High Gate (The Netherweird Chronicles, #2) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • fantasy
Cover of Lark Rising: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Three - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide by Violet Fenn

13. Lark Rising: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Three - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide

By: Violet Fenn

4.48

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

“My cat’s learned how to use the remote control, vampires keep ambushing me and I just kicked one o… read more

Similar categories in Violet Fenn's Lark Rising: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Three - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • fantasy
Cover of Eye of the Sh*t Storm (The Frost Files, #3) by Jackson Ford

14. Eye of the Sh*t Storm (The Frost Files, #3)

By: Jackson Ford

4.00

Format: 496 pages, Paperback

Teagan Frost might be getting better at moving sh*t with her mind – but her job working as a teleki… read more

Similar categories in Jackson Ford's Eye of the Sh*t Storm (The Frost Files, #3) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • science fiction fantasy
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
Cover of City of Ghosts: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Four - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide by Violet Fenn

15. City of Ghosts: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Four - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide

By: Violet Fenn

4.44

Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition

“The city keeps dropping people into the past, big cats are prowling Toxteth, and riding the Albert… read more

Similar categories in Violet Fenn's City of Ghosts: The Netherweird Chronicles, Book Four - paranormal urban fantasy, where history and mythology collide book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • fantasy
Cover of Bitter Waters (Dr. Greta Helsing, #3.5) by Vivian Shaw

16. Bitter Waters (Dr. Greta Helsing, #3.5)

By: Vivian Shaw

4.38

Format: 164 pages, Kindle Edition

A witty, charming standalone novella starring Greta Helsing, doctor to the undead, who must get to … read more

Similar categories in Vivian Shaw's Bitter Waters (Dr. Greta Helsing, #3.5) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • science fiction fantasy
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Elusive (Scarlet Revolution, #2) by Genevieve Cogman

17. Elusive (Scarlet Revolution, #2)

By: Genevieve Cogman

4.13

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Revolutionary France is full of blood and bite as vampires plot for power. Eleanor, once a lowly… read more

Similar categories in Genevieve Cogman's Elusive (Scarlet Revolution, #2) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • audiobook
Cover of Witch Slap (The Hollowbeck Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 1) by Amelia Ash

18. Witch Slap (The Hollowbeck Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 1)

By: Amelia Ash

4.35

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

Never let your brother date a witch, lest they get turned into a talking cat. Morgan Winters wants… read more

Similar categories in Amelia Ash's Witch Slap (The Hollowbeck Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 1) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • witches
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • fiction
Cover of The Lights Go Out in Lychford (Lychford, #4) by Paul Cornell

19. The Lights Go Out in Lychford (Lychford, #4)

By: Paul Cornell

4.00

Format: 162 pages, Kindle Edition

Be careful what you wish for… The continuing tale in the award-nominated Witches of Lychford ser… read more

Similar categories in Paul Cornell's The Lights Go Out in Lychford (Lychford, #4) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • urban fantasy
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
"...with a look on her face that said she had a lot of plates to juggle, but as long as you were prepared to be spun, everything would be fine."

-Paul Cornell, The Lights Go Out in Lychford (Lychford, #4)

Cover of One Smart Witch (The Hollowbeck Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 2) by Amelia Ash

20. One Smart Witch (The Hollowbeck Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 2)

By: Amelia Ash

4.46

Format: 276 pages, Kindle Edition

A talking cat accused of murder. A magical carnival with sinister secrets. And a sleuth who’s runni… read more

Similar categories in Amelia Ash's One Smart Witch (The Hollowbeck Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 2) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • fiction
Cover of Hidden Enemy (The Living Oracle #2) by Melissa McShane

21. Hidden Enemy (The Living Oracle #2)

By: Melissa McShane

4.18

Format: 256 pages, Kindle Edition

Return to the world of The Last Oracle! With the destruction of the barrier protecting our world f… read more

Similar categories in Melissa McShane's Hidden Enemy (The Living Oracle #2) book and Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

  • fantasy

13 Best fiction books like The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) by Sarah Painter

Transform Your Habits

Boy of Chaotic Making (Whimbrel House, #3)

Charlie N. Holmberg

4.32

Transform Your Habits

Killing Time (The Time Police, #5)

Jodi Taylor

4.56

Transform Your Habits

The Dead Letter Delivery (Glass Library, #4)

C.J. Archer

4.10

Transform Your Habits

The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

Sarah Painter

4.43

View all the books

24 must-read fantasy books like The High Gate (The Netherweird Chronicles, #2) by Violet Fenn

Transform Your Habits

The Crone of Midnight Embers (Myrtlewood Crones #1)

Iris Beaglehole

4.11

Transform Your Habits

Killing Time (The Time Police, #5)

Jodi Taylor

4.56

Transform Your Habits

The Crone of Solstice Flames: Myrtlewood Crones book 2

Iris Beaglehole

4.38

Transform Your Habits

imPerfect Magic (The imPerfect Cathar, #1)

C.N. Rowan

4.13

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.