21 best-selling romance books like Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless) by Brit Benson

Cover of Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless) by Brit Benson

Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

By: Brit Benson

4.25

Format: 530 pages, Kindle Edition

She was the first rule I ever broke. She’ll be the last. In the beginning, there was Savannah …

If you liked the romance plot in Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless) by Brit Benson , here is a list of 21 books like this:

Cover of Older by Jennifer Hartmann

1. Older

By: Jennifer Hartmann

4.13

Format: 436 pages, Kindle Edition

Before he discovered my age, he uncovered my heart. Bruised and abused, and victim to a loveless… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Hartmann's Older book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance
  • abuse
Cover of When We Lied (Fairview Hockey, #2) by Claire Contreras

2. When We Lied (Fairview Hockey, #2)

By: Claire Contreras

4.14

Format: 432 pages, ebook

A brand new hockey romance from New York Times Bestselling Author Claire Contreras set in the same … read more

Similar categories in Claire Contreras's When We Lied (Fairview Hockey, #2) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of Hawke by Jescie Hall

3. Hawke

By: Jescie Hall

4.06

Format: 400 pages, None

Nicole never imagined anyone other than her seemingly perfect boyfriend, Patrick, could grab her at… read more

Similar categories in Jescie Hall's Hawke book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • dark
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Fragile Sanctuary (Sparrow Falls, #1) by Catherine Cowles

4. Fragile Sanctuary (Sparrow Falls, #1)

By: Catherine Cowles

4.31

Format: 366 pages, Paperback

The scowl should’ve been my first clue to stay far away from Anson Hunt. The sexy smirk and the fac… read more

Similar categories in Catherine Cowles's Fragile Sanctuary (Sparrow Falls, #1) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Crossroads (Haven River Ranch, #1) by Devney Perry

5. Crossroads (Haven River Ranch, #1)

By: Devney Perry

4.20

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

A sweeping small-town romance about love, loss, and a Montana legacy from USA Today bestselling aut… read more

Similar categories in Devney Perry's Crossroads (Haven River Ranch, #1) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of The Summer I Destroyed You (The Summer #4) by Elizabeth O'Roark

6. The Summer I Destroyed You (The Summer #4)

By: Elizabeth O'Roark

4.13

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

“Destroying other people isn’t going to make you feel any better.”“That suggests you’ve never destr… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth O'Roark's The Summer I Destroyed You (The Summer #4) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Before We Came (Lakes Hockey, #1) by Sloane St. James

7. Before We Came (Lakes Hockey, #1)

By: Sloane St. James

3.84

Format: 434 pages, Kindle Edition

Birdie My mother's funeral unraveled decades of secrets hidden from me—horrible secrets. I’ve lear… read more

Similar categories in Sloane St. James's Before We Came (Lakes Hockey, #1) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of Rival Hearts (Queen City, #1) by Maggie Rawdon

8. Rival Hearts (Queen City, #1)

By: Maggie Rawdon

4.06

Format: 306 pages, Paperback

Pro football might see me as their favorite underdog, but Madison Westfield would rather see me six… read more

Similar categories in Maggie Rawdon's Rival Hearts (Queen City, #1) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless) by Brit Benson

9. Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

By: Brit Benson

4.25

Format: 530 pages, Kindle Edition

She was the first rule I ever broke. She’ll be the last. In the beginning, there was Savannah … read more

Similar categories in Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • music
  • musicians
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • dark
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance
  • abuse
  • audiobook
Cover of Learn Your Lesson (Kings of the Ice, #3) by Kandi Steiner

10. Learn Your Lesson (Kings of the Ice, #3)

By: Kandi Steiner

4.13

Format: 470 pages, Kindle Edition

My mother only wanted me to learn one lesson growing up… Men are trash. Her father left her, a… read more

Similar categories in Kandi Steiner's Learn Your Lesson (Kings of the Ice, #3) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
  • contemporary
Cover of Where We Started (Stone Riders MC, #1) by Ashley Munoz

11. Where We Started (Stone Riders MC, #1)

By: Ashley Munoz

4.07

Format: 316 pages, Paperback

Usually, watching a notorious biker club mourn the loss of their beloved president would be a dange… read more

Similar categories in Ashley Munoz's Where We Started (Stone Riders MC, #1) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of The Pieces We Leave Behind (Lost Hollow, #1) by Elle  Mitchell

12. The Pieces We Leave Behind (Lost Hollow, #1)

By: Elle Mitchell

4.03

Format: 333 pages, Kindle Edition

"It gets easier…I know it hurts now, but one day, you'll wake up, and you'll just be okay. It'll ha… read more

Similar categories in Elle Mitchell's The Pieces We Leave Behind (Lost Hollow, #1) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • dark
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of The Canary Cowards by Jescie Hall

13. The Canary Cowards

By: Jescie Hall

4.43

Format: 538 pages, Paperback

From Author Jescie Hall comes a compelling and angst-filled love story that will pull at your heart… read more

Similar categories in Jescie Hall's The Canary Cowards book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of So This Is War (Vancouver Agitators, #5) by Meghan Quinn

14. So This Is War (Vancouver Agitators, #5)

By: Meghan Quinn

4.06

Format: 446 pages, Kindle Edition

Did I think I was going to fall for my coach's daughter? The answer would be no. I'm still … read more

Similar categories in Meghan Quinn's So This Is War (Vancouver Agitators, #5) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Catch the Sun by Jennifer Hartmann

15. Catch the Sun

By: Jennifer Hartmann

4.43

Format: 448 pages, Paperback

"Kissing you feels like catching the sun…" At seven years old, Ella Sunbury and Max Manning wer… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Hartmann's Catch the Sun book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of When the Stars Fall (Lost Stars) by Emery Rose Andrews

16. When the Stars Fall (Lost Stars)

By: Emery Rose Andrews

4.12

Format: 436 pages, Paperback

Emery Rose delivers an emotionally gripping, angsty, and epic love story with ALL the feels. Gro… read more

Similar categories in Emery Rose Andrews's When the Stars Fall (Lost Stars) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of Our Little Secret (Secrets #3) by Q.B. Tyler

17. Our Little Secret (Secrets #3)

By: Q.B. Tyler

3.98

Format: 328 pages, Kindle Edition

Three months ago, I had the best night of my life at my friend’s wedding.The man was confident, smo… read more

Similar categories in Q.B. Tyler's Our Little Secret (Secrets #3) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
  • contemporary
Cover of Green Light by Jescie Hall

18. Green Light

By: Jescie Hall

4.26

Format: 565 pages, Kindle Edition

From Amazon's bestselling author Jescie Hall comes a new dark college romance about one man's onlin… read more

Similar categories in Jescie Hall's Green Light book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance
Cover of When the Stars Rise (Lost Stars) by Emery Rose Andrews

19. When the Stars Rise (Lost Stars)

By: Emery Rose Andrews

4.14

Format: 474 pages, Paperback

Six weeks. Thirty-five cities. One more chance to get it right. Noah McCallister. Extreme athle… read more

Similar categories in Emery Rose Andrews's When the Stars Rise (Lost Stars) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • music
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of The Summer I First Saw You (The Summer, #5) by Elizabeth O'Roark

20. The Summer I First Saw You (The Summer, #5)

By: Elizabeth O'Roark

4.20

Format: 312 pages, Paperback

An angsty, age gap, forbidden romance from bestselling author, Elizabeth O’ Roark.Once upon a time,… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth O'Roark's The Summer I First Saw You (The Summer, #5) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
  • contemporary
Cover of Bitter Rival (Sutton Ridge #1) by Emery Rose Andrews

21. Bitter Rival (Sutton Ridge #1)

By: Emery Rose Andrews

4.26

Format: 392 pages, Kindle Edition

Spending the summer on a vineyard sounds idyllic. Unfortunately, my California dream comes with str… read more

Similar categories in Emery Rose Andrews's Bitter Rival (Sutton Ridge #1) book and Brit Benson's Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary

10 best-selling fiction books like Between Never and Forever (The Hometown Heartless) by Brit Benson

Transform Your Habits

Hawke

Jescie Hall

4.06

Transform Your Habits

Fragile Sanctuary (Sparrow Falls, #1)

Catherine Cowles

4.31

Transform Your Habits

Crossroads (Haven River Ranch, #1)

Devney Perry

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Rival Hearts (Queen City, #1)

Maggie Rawdon

4.06

View all the books

18 best-selling contemporary books like When We Lied (Fairview Hockey, #2) by Claire Contreras

Transform Your Habits

When We Lied (Fairview Hockey, #2)

Claire Contreras

4.14

Transform Your Habits

The Dixon Rule (Campus Diaries, #2)

Elle Kennedy

4.20

Transform Your Habits

The Puck Decoy (Fairfield U, #2)

G.N. Wright

4.09

Transform Your Habits

Before We Came (Lakes Hockey, #1)

Sloane St. James

3.84

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.