30 Top romance books like The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3) by Maya Hughes

Cover of The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3) by Maya Hughes

The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

By: Maya Hughes

4.05

Format: 406 pages, Kindle Edition

Dear Letter Girl, I need to see you. When can we meet?Her response never came. My secret pen pal wi…

If you liked the romance plot in The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3) by Maya Hughes , here is a list of 30 books like this:

Cover of Playing Hard to Get (The Players, #1) by Monica  Murphy

1. Playing Hard to Get (The Players, #1)

By: Monica Murphy

3.77

Format: 398 pages, Kindle Edition

Knox Maguire is the king of our college campus. Star offensive tight end on the football team. … read more

Similar categories in Monica Murphy's Playing Hard to Get (The Players, #1) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • football
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Camera Shy (Lessons in Love, #1) by Kay Cove

2. Camera Shy (Lessons in Love, #1)

By: Kay Cove

4.02

Format: 446 pages, ebook

In this special limited edition hardcover, a body positive, neighbors-to-lovers romance about a cur… read more

Similar categories in Kay Cove's Camera Shy (Lessons in Love, #1) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • new adult
  • contemporary romance
  • plus size
Cover of I Bet You (Waylon University, #2) by Ilsa Madden-Mills

3. I Bet You (Waylon University, #2)

By: Ilsa Madden-Mills

4.03

Format: 298 pages, Paperback

New Standalone Sports Romance Sexy Athlete: I bet you . . . Penelope Graham: Burn in hell, qua… read more

Similar categories in Ilsa Madden-Mills's I Bet You (Waylon University, #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of The Dare (Briar U, #4) by Elle Kennedy

4. The Dare (Briar U, #4)

By: Elle Kennedy

3.76

Format: 354 pages, Paperback

College was supposed to be my chance to get over my ugly-duckling complex and spread my wings. Inst… read more

Similar categories in Elle Kennedy's The Dare (Briar U, #4) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
"- Never. I've gone completely mar for you, Taylor Antonia Marsh. - That's not even my middle name! - It's a middle name and I don't care"

-Elle Kennedy, The Dare (Briar U, #4)

Cover of Dear Grumpy Boss (The Harder They Fall, #1) by Julia  Wolf

5. Dear Grumpy Boss (The Harder They Fall, #1)

By: Julia Wolf

3.92

Format: 414 pages, Kindle Edition

I’ve spent the better part of the last few years successfully avoiding my brother’s best friend, We… read more

Similar categories in Julia Wolf's Dear Grumpy Boss (The Harder They Fall, #1) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • new adult
  • contemporary romance
  • plus size
Cover of Hail Mary (Red Zone Rivals, #4) by Kandi Steiner

6. Hail Mary (Red Zone Rivals, #4)

By: Kandi Steiner

4.03

Format: 436 pages, Kindle Edition

Leo F*cking Hernandez. North Boston University’s star running back, notorious bachelor, and numb… read more

Similar categories in Kandi Steiner's Hail Mary (Red Zone Rivals, #4) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • football
  • new adult
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
Cover of Fumbled Love by Lila Rose

7. Fumbled Love

By: Lila Rose

4.17

Format: 284 pages, ebook

(A BBW romantic comedy) The one day English teacher Reagan Wild is late for work—and looks like… read more

Similar categories in Lila Rose's Fumbled Love book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • contemporary
  • new adult
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
Cover of Real Players Never Lose (The Boys, #3) by Micalea Smeltzer

8. Real Players Never Lose (The Boys, #3)

By: Micalea Smeltzer

4.05

Format: 450 pages, Kindle Edition

I’ve heard the whispers on campus of what a player Teddy McCallister is. Most girls on campus are v… read more

Similar categories in Micalea Smeltzer's Real Players Never Lose (The Boys, #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • contemporary
  • new adult
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
Cover of P.S. You're Intolerable (The Harder They Fall, #3) by Julia  Wolf

9. P.S. You're Intolerable (The Harder They Fall, #3)

By: Julia Wolf

4.19

Format: 394 pages, Kindle Edition

My boss, Elliot Levy is intolerable, and I tell him so everyday…in the little notes I write and the… read more

Similar categories in Julia Wolf's P.S. You're Intolerable (The Harder They Fall, #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • new adult
  • contemporary romance
  • plus size
"I've got so much cum for you, sweetheart. Gonna fuck you again and again until you give me another baby."

-Julia Wolf, P.S. You're Intolerable (The Harder They Fall, #3)

Cover of Weak Side (Bexley U) by S.J. Sylvis

10. Weak Side (Bexley U)

By: S.J. Sylvis

3.97

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

He’s the hottest hockey player in the nation, and I just agreed to be his fake girlfriend. Theo … read more

Similar categories in S.J. Sylvis's Weak Side (Bexley U) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Tempting the Player (Campus Wallflowers #4) by Rebecca Jenshak

11. Tempting the Player (Campus Wallflowers #4)

By: Rebecca Jenshak

3.89

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

He’s the last guy I should fall for. Valley U was supposed to be my fresh start after I escaped … read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Jenshak's Tempting the Player (Campus Wallflowers #4) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Tutoring the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #1) by Rebecca Jenshak

12. Tutoring the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #1)

By: Rebecca Jenshak

3.72

Format: None pages, ebook

A sexy opposites attract standalone novel from USA Today bestselling author Rebecca Jenshak. I h… read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Jenshak's Tutoring the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #1) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Hating the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #2) by Rebecca Jenshak

13. Hating the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #2)

By: Rebecca Jenshak

3.84

Format: 302 pages, Kindle Edition

Gavin Leonard is the worst. He lives in the best party house off campus at Valley U, overrun by jo… read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Jenshak's Hating the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Scoring the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #3) by Rebecca Jenshak

14. Scoring the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #3)

By: Rebecca Jenshak

4.01

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

Valley U’s hottest QB has heard in detail how I want to climb him like a tree. One viral video and… read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Jenshak's Scoring the Player (Campus Wallflowers, #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Bad Crush (Campus Nights, #2) by Rebecca Jenshak

15. Bad Crush (Campus Nights, #2)

By: Rebecca Jenshak

3.94

Format: 323 pages, Kindle Edition

Reasons not to crush on Adam: He's my best friend's brother. He's my neighbor. He's the captain … read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Jenshak's Bad Crush (Campus Nights, #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • college
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Broken Hearts (Campus Nights, #3) by Rebecca Jenshak

16. Broken Hearts (Campus Nights, #3)

By: Rebecca Jenshak

3.88

Format: None pages, Paperback

She’s a figure skater. He’s a hockey player. Things are about to heat up on the ice. Rhett Rauth… read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Jenshak's Broken Hearts (Campus Nights, #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Spin the Bottle (Campus Games, #2) by Stephanie Alves

17. Spin the Bottle (Campus Games, #2)

By: Stephanie Alves

3.72

Format: 388 pages, Kindle Edition

Spin the bottle to decide your fate Leila I have rules. Dating? Out of the question. One night … read more

Similar categories in Stephanie Alves's Spin the Bottle (Campus Games, #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
Cover of Ruthless Knight (Royal Hearts Academy, #2) by Ashley Jade

18. Ruthless Knight (Royal Hearts Academy, #2)

By: Ashley Jade

4.28

Format: 608 pages, None

WARNING: Royal Hearts Academy is a New Adult/High School series of standalones filled with drama, … read more

Similar categories in Ashley Jade's Ruthless Knight (Royal Hearts Academy, #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
  • new adult
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
"Entitlement is laziness wrapped up in selfishness."

-Ashley Jade, Ruthless Knight (Royal Hearts Academy, #2)

"Jealousy is insecurity wrapped up in self-loathing, because deep down, you think you’re not good enough."

-Ashley Jade, Ruthless Knight (Royal Hearts Academy, #2)

Cover of Stone Cold Notes (The Seasons Change) by Julia  Wolf

19. Stone Cold Notes (The Seasons Change)

By: Julia Wolf

3.98

Format: 346 pages, Kindle Edition

They called him Stone Cold. Once upon a time, I called him my pen pal. When I wrote to Callum… read more

Similar categories in Julia Wolf's Stone Cold Notes (The Seasons Change) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • plus size
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Built to Fall by Julia  Wolf

20. Built to Fall

By: Julia Wolf

4.14

Format: 331 pages, Kindle Edition

“You’re perfect for this job, Claire. He won’t want to sleep with you. You’re not his...type.” D… read more

Similar categories in Julia Wolf's Built to Fall book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • plus size
Cover of The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3) by Maya Hughes

21. The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

By: Maya Hughes

4.05

Format: 406 pages, Kindle Edition

Dear Letter Girl, I need to see you. When can we meet?Her response never came. My secret pen pal wi… read more

Similar categories in Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • football
  • new adult
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
Cover of Blind Side (Red Zone Rivals, #2) by Kandi Steiner

22. Blind Side (Red Zone Rivals, #2)

By: Kandi Steiner

3.99

Format: 408 pages, Kindle Edition

The hottest college football safety in the nation just asked me to be his fake girlfriend. And I… read more

Similar categories in Kandi Steiner's Blind Side (Red Zone Rivals, #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • football
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Quarterback Sneak (Red Zone Rivals, #3) by Kandi Steiner

23. Quarterback Sneak (Red Zone Rivals, #3)

By: Kandi Steiner

3.99

Format: 352 pages, Kindle Edition

Quarterback Holden Moore can have any girl he wants. Except me: the coach’s daughter. With pi… read more

Similar categories in Kandi Steiner's Quarterback Sneak (Red Zone Rivals, #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • football
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
"He'd fill me with life, even when I hadn't asked for it."

-Kandi Steiner, Quarterback Sneak (Red Zone Rivals, #3)

Cover of False Start (Red Zone Rivals, #5) by Kandi Steiner

24. False Start (Red Zone Rivals, #5)

By: Kandi Steiner

4.00

Format: 439 pages, Kindle Edition

Kyle Robbins: Seattle's rookie tight end and the first boy to break my heart. Oh, did I mention he… read more

Similar categories in Kandi Steiner's False Start (Red Zone Rivals, #5) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of These Two Wrongs (Savage Academy, #2) by Julia  Wolf

25. These Two Wrongs (Savage Academy, #2)

By: Julia Wolf

4.24

Format: 334 pages, Kindle Edition

The universe must really hate me. Rhys Astor, the guy with a deadly smirk and devil-may-care att… read more

Similar categories in Julia Wolf's These Two Wrongs (Savage Academy, #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Griz (Westbury Warriors #3) by E. Cleveland

26. Griz (Westbury Warriors #3)

By: E. Cleveland

3.99

Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition

This fake relationship romance has it all! Funny, awkward moments. The “will they or won’t they”? A… read more

Similar categories in E. Cleveland's Griz (Westbury Warriors #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • contemporary
  • new adult
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
Cover of Broken Boys Can't Love (The Boys, #5) by Micalea Smeltzer

27. Broken Boys Can't Love (The Boys, #5)

By: Micalea Smeltzer

4.03

Format: 318 pages, Kindle Edition

Off-limits. That’s what Jude is to me. My older brother doesn’t trust me with his player of a… read more

Similar categories in Micalea Smeltzer's Broken Boys Can't Love (The Boys, #5) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Fair Catch (Red Zone Rivals, #1) by Kandi Steiner

28. Fair Catch (Red Zone Rivals, #1)

By: Kandi Steiner

3.70

Format: 362 pages, Paperback

As if things aren’t already tough enough as the only girl on a college football team, Coach had to … read more

Similar categories in Kandi Steiner's Fair Catch (Red Zone Rivals, #1) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • football
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
"No matter what came our way, I knew one thing for sure. We’d fight it. Together. And just like tonight… We’d win."

-Kandi Steiner, Fair Catch (Red Zone Rivals, #1)

Cover of Love, Utley (Love Letters, #1) by S.J. Tilly

29. Love, Utley (Love Letters, #1)

By: S.J. Tilly

4.16

Format: 428 pages, Paperback

Hannah Maddox Lovelace. The captivating football player I met in college. The one I only knew … read more

Similar categories in S.J. Tilly's Love, Utley (Love Letters, #1) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • plus size
Cover of Burn it Down (The Savage Crew, #3) by Julia  Wolf

30. Burn it Down (The Savage Crew, #3)

By: Julia Wolf

4.23

Format: 343 pages, Kindle Edition

I’m the smart girl with my nose constantly in a book. The one with the level head who never breaks … read more

Similar categories in Julia Wolf's Burn it Down (The Savage Crew, #3) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • college
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of Playbook (The Holland Brothers #2) by Rebecca Jenshak

31. Playbook (The Holland Brothers #2)

By: Rebecca Jenshak

4.14

Format: 460 pages, Kindle Edition

From USA Today bestselling author Rebecca Jenshak comes a standalone fake dating sports romance. Th… read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Jenshak's Playbook (The Holland Brothers #2) book and Maya Hughes's The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult

18 Best fiction books like The Third Best Thing (Fulton U, #3) by Maya Hughes

Transform Your Habits

Playing Hard to Get (The Players, #1)

Monica Murphy

3.77

Transform Your Habits

Camera Shy (Lessons in Love, #1)

Kay Cove

4.02

Transform Your Habits

The Dare (Briar U, #4)

Elle Kennedy

3.76

Transform Your Habits

Dear Grumpy Boss (The Harder They Fall, #1)

Julia Wolf

3.92

View all the books

18 best-selling contemporary books like Tempting the Player (Campus Wallflowers #4) by Rebecca Jenshak

Transform Your Habits

The Dixon Rule (Campus Diaries, #2)

Elle Kennedy

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Against All Odds (Holt Hockey, #2)

C.W. Farnsworth

3.99

Transform Your Habits

Offside Play (Sin Bin Stories #1)

Lyssa Lemire

3.64

Transform Your Habits

Tempting the Player (Campus Wallflowers #4)

Rebecca Jenshak

3.89

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.