13 must-read fantasy books like Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1) by Celestine Martin

Cover of Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1) by Celestine Martin

Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

By: Celestine Martin

3.46

Format: 333 pages, Paperback

Love is the trickiest spell of all.   Lucinda Caraway loves living in Freya Grove, the mystic sea…

If you liked the fantasy plot in Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1) by Celestine Martin , here is a list of 13 books like this:

Cover of The Neighbor Favor (The Greene Sisters) by Kristina Forest

1. The Neighbor Favor (The Greene Sisters)

By: Kristina Forest

3.82

Format: 403 pages, Paperback

In this heart-fluttering romance by Kristina Forest, a shy bookworm enlists her charming neighbor t… read more

Similar categories in Kristina Forest's The Neighbor Favor (The Greene Sisters) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"For a moment, Nick was speechless. She thought she needed his help flirting? From what had just happened up- stairs in her kitchen, she was the master and he was the novice. He'd practically fallen a…"

-Kristina Forest, The Neighbor Favor (The Greene Sisters)

Cover of Even If the Sky Is Falling by Taj McCoy

2. Even If the Sky Is Falling

By: Taj McCoy

3.43

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

It’s the end of the world as they know it—or so they think… When an international warning siren acc… read more

Similar categories in Taj McCoy's Even If the Sky Is Falling book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Extra Witchy (Fix-It Witches, #3) by Ann Aguirre

3. Extra Witchy (Fix-It Witches, #3)

By: Ann Aguirre

3.76

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

After two failed marriages, Leanne Vanderpol is here for a good time, not for a long time. She only… read more

Similar categories in Ann Aguirre's Extra Witchy (Fix-It Witches, #3) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
Cover of The Partner Plot (The Greene Sisters) by Kristina Forest

4. The Partner Plot (The Greene Sisters)

By: Kristina Forest

3.80

Format: 416 pages, Paperback

Two former high school sweethearts get a second chance in this marriage of convenience romance by K… read more

Similar categories in Kristina Forest's The Partner Plot (The Greene Sisters) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Witcha Gonna Do? (Witchington #1) by Avery Flynn

5. Witcha Gonna Do? (Witchington #1)

By: Avery Flynn

3.11

Format: 312 pages, Paperback

An unlucky witch and her know-it-all nemesis must team up in the first of a new, spicy romantic com… read more

Similar categories in Avery Flynn's Witcha Gonna Do? (Witchington #1) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
Cover of In Charm's Way (The Witches of Thistle Grove, #4) by Lana Harper

6. In Charm's Way (The Witches of Thistle Grove, #4)

By: Lana Harper

3.56

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

A witch struggling to regain what she has lost casts a forbidden spell—only to discover much more t… read more

Similar categories in Lana Harper's In Charm's Way (The Witches of Thistle Grove, #4) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Small Town, Big Magic (Witchlore, #1) by Hazel Beck

7. Small Town, Big Magic (Witchlore, #1)

By: Hazel Beck

3.32

Format: 411 pages, Paperback

A witchy rom-com in which a bookstore owner who is fighting to revitalize a small midwestern town c… read more

Similar categories in Hazel Beck's Small Town, Big Magic (Witchlore, #1) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • magic
  • halloween
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
"But I have always believed that a woman's best and biggest champion should be herself. The world sure isn't going to step up and cheer on its own."

-Hazel Beck, Small Town, Big Magic (Witchlore, #1)

Cover of Mickey Chambers Shakes It Up by Charish Reid

8. Mickey Chambers Shakes It Up

By: Charish Reid

3.95

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Total opposites. Totally irresistible. Mickey Chambers is an expert at analyzing modern literat… read more

Similar categories in Charish Reid's Mickey Chambers Shakes It Up book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1) by Celestine Martin

9. Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

By: Celestine Martin

3.46

Format: 333 pages, Paperback

Love is the trickiest spell of all.   Lucinda Caraway loves living in Freya Grove, the mystic sea… read more

Similar categories in Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • halloween
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
Cover of Not Your Ex's Hexes (Supernatural Singles, #2) by April Asher

10. Not Your Ex's Hexes (Supernatural Singles, #2)

By: April Asher

3.84

Format: 343 pages, Paperback

In April Asher’s next Supernatural Singles novel, a one-night-stand between a willful witch and a b… read more

Similar categories in April Asher's Not Your Ex's Hexes (Supernatural Singles, #2) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of The Kiss Countdown by Etta Easton

11. The Kiss Countdown

By: Etta Easton

3.84

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

A struggling event planner and a sinfully hot astronaut must decide if their fake relationship is w… read more

Similar categories in Etta Easton's The Kiss Countdown book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"You want to know what I love about the moon?…It gives me perspective. The moon was here when Earth was still forming. She is billions of years old and still there. She can be testy sometimes, and why…"

-Etta Easton, The Kiss Countdown

Cover of The Good Ones Are Taken by Taj McCoy

12. The Good Ones Are Taken

By: Taj McCoy

3.55

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

When Maggie's best friend admits he's in love with her, she'll have to decide whether it's worth gi… read more

Similar categories in Taj McCoy's The Good Ones Are Taken book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Big Little Spells (Witchlore, #2) by Hazel Beck

13. Big Little Spells (Witchlore, #2)

By: Hazel Beck

3.81

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Is her magic a threat to witchkind…or is she simply powerful enough to save the world? Rebekah W… read more

Similar categories in Hazel Beck's Big Little Spells (Witchlore, #2) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • magic
  • halloween
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
Cover of Full Moon Over Freedom (Milagro Street, #2) by Angelina M. Lopez

14. Full Moon Over Freedom (Milagro Street, #2)

By: Angelina M. Lopez

3.95

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

Gillian Armstead-Bancroft—Pride of the East Side and once-perfect bruja, wife, and mother—is going … read more

Similar categories in Angelina M. Lopez's Full Moon Over Freedom (Milagro Street, #2) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
Cover of Out of Office by A.H. Cunningham

15. Out of Office

By: A.H. Cunningham

3.56

Format: None pages, Paperback

A.H. Cunningham dazzles in this sensual vacation romance exploring what happens when you step out o… read more

Similar categories in A.H. Cunningham's Out of Office book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Back in a Spell (The Witches of Thistle Grove, #3) by Lana Harper

16. Back in a Spell (The Witches of Thistle Grove, #3)

By: Lana Harper

3.73

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Even though she won’t deny her love for pretty (and pricey) things, Nineve Blackmoore is almost pai… read more

Similar categories in Lana Harper's Back in a Spell (The Witches of Thistle Grove, #3) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • witches
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
Cover of Play to Win by Jodie Slaughter

17. Play to Win

By: Jodie Slaughter

3.38

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Jodie Slaughter's latest rom-com, Play to Win , is a sizzling romance where a winning lottery ticke… read more

Similar categories in Jodie Slaughter's Play to Win book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1) by Sophie H. Morgan

18. The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1)

By: Sophie H. Morgan

3.57

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Love is a hex of a thing. Former childhood sweethearts fake a relationship in this charming, witchy… read more

Similar categories in Sophie H. Morgan's The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
"Bastian cleared his throat. Looked off to the distance. "Moot point. Look, I get why she did what she did. But it's that she didn't tell me, even after we..." He stopped. "Made sweet, sweet love?" Et…"

-Sophie H. Morgan, The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1)

Cover of Not the Witch You Wed (Supernatural Singles, #1) by April Asher

19. Not the Witch You Wed (Supernatural Singles, #1)

By: April Asher

3.79

Format: 341 pages, Paperback

A fake relationship between a magic-less witch and a wolf shifter turns to more in the start of a b… read more

Similar categories in April Asher's Not the Witch You Wed (Supernatural Singles, #1) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
"I'm extremely allergic to the term fine. More often than not, it's hiding a total clusterfuck beneath its rather dull surface."

-April Asher, Not the Witch You Wed (Supernatural Singles, #1)

"Rose's eyebrows lifted toward her hairline. "You bought the man a gift? For taking you to dinner? His gift is the honor of your presence and your time."

-April Asher, Not the Witch You Wed (Supernatural Singles, #1)

Cover of Not Your Crush's Cauldron (Supernatural Singles, #3) by April Asher

20. Not Your Crush's Cauldron (Supernatural Singles, #3)

By: April Asher

3.81

Format: 327 pages, Paperback

In April Asher's new Supernatural Singles novel, a witch takes a stroll on the wild-ish side, spark… read more

Similar categories in April Asher's Not Your Crush's Cauldron (Supernatural Singles, #3) book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
Cover of Mr. & Mrs. Witch by Gwenda Bond

21. Mr. & Mrs. Witch

By: Gwenda Bond

3.49

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

In Mr. & Mrs. Witch, the next novel from bestselling author Gwenda Bond, a couple discovers at the … read more

Similar categories in Gwenda Bond's Mr. & Mrs. Witch book and Celestine Martin's Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • audiobook

20 best-selling fiction books like Witchful Thinking (Elemental Love, #1) by Celestine Martin

Transform Your Habits

The Neighbor Favor (The Greene Sisters)

Kristina Forest

3.82

Transform Your Habits

Even If the Sky Is Falling

Taj McCoy

3.43

Transform Your Habits

Extra Witchy (Fix-It Witches, #3)

Ann Aguirre

3.76

Transform Your Habits

The Partner Plot (The Greene Sisters)

Kristina Forest

3.80

View all the books

18 Top fiction books like Mr. & Mrs. Witch by Gwenda Bond

Transform Your Habits

The Only Purple House in Town (Fix-It Witches, #4)

Ann Aguirre

3.44

Transform Your Habits

Nevermore Bookstore (Townsend Harbor, #1)

Kerrigan Byrne

3.58

Transform Your Habits

What the Hex (Hex, #2)

Jessica Clare

3.73

Transform Your Habits

Enchanted to Meet You (Witches of West Harbor, #1)

Meg Cabot

3.33

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.