21 Top contemporary romance books like Accidentally Amy by Lynn Painter

Cover of Accidentally Amy by Lynn Painter

Accidentally Amy

By: Lynn Painter

3.50

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

IT STARTED WITH A CUP… Isabella Shay is usually a very honest person. But when she’s running …

If you liked the contemporary romance plot in Accidentally Amy by Lynn Painter , here is a list of 21 books like this:

Cover of Next of Kin (Next, #1) by Hannah Bonam-Young

1. Next of Kin (Next, #1)

By: Hannah Bonam-Young

3.80

Format: 295 pages, Paperback

When people-pleasing Chloe learns that her birth mother has unexpectedly had another baby, she does… read more

Similar categories in Hannah Bonam-Young's Next of Kin (Next, #1) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
"I want to keep all of you," Warren says, blue eyes pinning me to where I sit."

-Hannah Bonam-Young, Next of Kin (Next, #1)

"Does he know how long I have wanted to hear someone say that to me? To feel in my bones that they mean it?"

-Hannah Bonam-Young, Next of Kin (Next, #1)

Cover of Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3) by Abby Jimenez

2. Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3)

By: Abby Jimenez

4.40

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

Justin has a curse, and thanks to a Reddit thread, it's now all over the internet. Every woman he d… read more

Similar categories in Abby Jimenez's Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
"I'm going to let that tall drink of water slam me like a door."

-Abby Jimenez, Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3)

"I swear to God this guy is the epitome of If He Wanted To He Would."

-Abby Jimenez, Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3)

"The best kind of love doesn't happen on moonlit walks and romantic vacations. It happens in between the folds of everyday life."

-Abby Jimenez, Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3)

"I’ve been waiting my whole life to feel like this and I thought it was a curse that nobody else ever worked out. But it wasn’t. It’s just that they weren’t you."

-Abby Jimenez, Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3)

Cover of Fangirl Down (Big Shots, #1) by Tessa Bailey

3. Fangirl Down (Big Shots, #1)

By: Tessa Bailey

3.90

Format: 380 pages, Kindle Edition

#1 New York Times bestselling author Tessa Bailey launches a super sexy sports romance series with … read more

Similar categories in Tessa Bailey's Fangirl Down (Big Shots, #1) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
"I just…have this pretty intense need to make sure everyone knows you’re very fucking important. Okay? Could you kindly just go along with it?"

-Tessa Bailey, Fangirl Down (Big Shots, #1)

"She jackknifed on the couch, screaming so loud that it could be heard clear to Orlando. This was it. Her Dateline moment. A robbery gone wrong. Or was it?, questioned Keith Morrison."

-Tessa Bailey, Fangirl Down (Big Shots, #1)

Cover of The Paradise Problem by Christina Lauren

4. The Paradise Problem

By: Christina Lauren

4.14

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

Christina Lauren, returns with a delicious new romance between the buttoned-up heir of a grocery ch… read more

Similar categories in Christina Lauren's The Paradise Problem book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • humor
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
"When we care about someone, they deserve the benefit of the doubt. We have to consider not only what they did, but also why they did it. Intent matters"

-Christina Lauren, The Paradise Problem

Cover of Not in Love by Ali Hazelwood

5. Not in Love

By: Ali Hazelwood

3.68

Format: 384 pages, Kindle Edition

A forbidden, secret affair proves that all’s fair in love and science. Rue Siebert might not ha… read more

Similar categories in Ali Hazelwood's Not in Love book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
"I'd been an odd child, then an odd teenager. Then I'd become, maybe as a result, maybe unavoidably, an odd adult."

-Ali Hazelwood, Not in Love

"I'd never felt more beautiful than when he looked at me. Like I was the final prototype of someone's entire fantasy life."

-Ali Hazelwood, Not in Love

"Eli was entranced. Her servant. Spellbound. He considered begging her to let him touch her. To let him go down on her in the hallway. He would go grocery shopping and make her dinner off a YouTube re…"

-Ali Hazelwood, Not in Love

"I'm going to want to see you every day. I'm going to learn more dishes and pack your lunch and write cute little notes on it. I'm going to ask you if you want to sleep at your place or mine and alway…"

-Ali Hazelwood, Not in Love

Cover of The Rom-Commers by Katherine Center

6. The Rom-Commers

By: Katherine Center

4.15

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

She’s rewriting his love story. But can she rewrite her own? Emma Wheeler desperately longs to … read more

Similar categories in Katherine Center's The Rom-Commers book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • humor
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
"We don't get to know the whole story all at once. And where we're headed matters so much less than how we get there."

-Katherine Center, The Rom-Commers

"If my life were a screenplay, I'd end the story right there and roll credits - and then maybe rewind and watch it again."

-Katherine Center, The Rom-Commers

"But, it was okay. We don't get to know the whole story all at once. And where we're headed matters so much less than how we get there."

-Katherine Center, The Rom-Commers

"Humanity at its worst is an easy story to tell - but it's not the only story. Because the more we can imagine our better selves, the more we can become them."

-Katherine Center, The Rom-Commers

Cover of The Rule Book (The Cheat Sheet, #2) by Sarah       Adams

7. The Rule Book (The Cheat Sheet, #2)

By: Sarah Adams

3.92

Format: 356 pages, Paperback

College exes break all the rules when they reunite years later in this enemies-to-lovers, second-ch… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Adams's The Rule Book (The Cheat Sheet, #2) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Roommate Pact by Allison Ashley

8. The Roommate Pact

By: Allison Ashley

3.68

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

All of the fun, none of the heartache…as long as they stick to the agreement. The proposition is… read more

Similar categories in Allison Ashley's The Roommate Pact book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Long Game (The Long Game, #1) by Elena  Armas

9. The Long Game (The Long Game, #1)

By: Elena Armas

3.59

Format: 373 pages, Paperback

A disgraced soccer exec reluctantly enlists the help of a retired soccer star in coaching a childre… read more

Similar categories in Elena Armas's The Long Game (The Long Game, #1) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Worst Wingman Ever (The Improbable Meet-Cute, #2) by Abby Jimenez

10. Worst Wingman Ever (The Improbable Meet-Cute, #2)

By: Abby Jimenez

4.00

Format: 61 pages, Kindle Edition

They’re falling in love, yet they’ve never met. Maybe fate can intervene in a heartwarming “what-if… read more

Similar categories in Abby Jimenez's Worst Wingman Ever (The Improbable Meet-Cute, #2) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
"We need to manifest our own destiny. I never accepted less than what I deserved ever again."

-Abby Jimenez, Worst Wingman Ever (The Improbable Meet-Cute, #2)

"I don't know how, but it felt like this stranger was a guardian angel. Like the universe, had put him here to be there when i needed him, with his small giant acts of kindness. That's the thing about…"

-Abby Jimenez, Worst Wingman Ever (The Improbable Meet-Cute, #2)

Cover of Practice Makes Perfect (When in Rome, #2) by Sarah       Adams

11. Practice Makes Perfect (When in Rome, #2)

By: Sarah Adams

4.02

Format: 335 pages, Paperback

A small-town sweetheart and an emotionally unavailable bad boy try to find some common ground in th… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Adams's Practice Makes Perfect (When in Rome, #2) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Honeymoon Crashers (Unhoneymooners, #1.5) by Christina Lauren

12. The Honeymoon Crashers (Unhoneymooners, #1.5)

By: Christina Lauren

3.58

Format: 5 pages, Audiobook

4 hours, 47 minutes A perfectionist maid of honor and a carefree, surfer-bro best man team up t… read more

Similar categories in Christina Lauren's The Honeymoon Crashers (Unhoneymooners, #1.5) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • humor
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Accidentally Amy by Lynn Painter

13. Accidentally Amy

By: Lynn Painter

3.50

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

IT STARTED WITH A CUP… Isabella Shay is usually a very honest person. But when she’s running … read more

Similar categories in Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • humor
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Lovelight Farms (Lovelight, #1) by B.K. Borison

14. Lovelight Farms (Lovelight, #1)

By: B.K. Borison

3.91

Format: 332 pages, Kindle Edition

Two best friends fake date to reach their holiday happily ever after in this first romantic comedy … read more

Similar categories in B.K. Borison's Lovelight Farms (Lovelight, #1) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
"It’s like the North Pole had a love child with Hogwarts! I want to live here forever!"

-B.K. Borison, Lovelight Farms (Lovelight, #1)

"It’s hard enough maintaining the charade of a fake relationship; now I have some mystery trespasser wreaking havoc."

-B.K. Borison, Lovelight Farms (Lovelight, #1)

"The first video is me explaining that I’m at Lovelight Farms where two idiots think they’re pretending to be in love."

-B.K. Borison, Lovelight Farms (Lovelight, #1)

"This feels like an oversimplification of a complicated addition to an irreplaceable relationship. I’ve watched enough romantic comedies to know that this is probably going to end badly for one of us,…"

-B.K. Borison, Lovelight Farms (Lovelight, #1)

Cover of When in Rome (When in Rome, #1) by Sarah       Adams

15. When in Rome (When in Rome, #1)

By: Sarah Adams

3.90

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Opposites certainly attract for the stranded pop star and small-town baker in this charming slice o… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Adams's When in Rome (When in Rome, #1) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
"No one loves anything they're miserably chained to."

-Sarah Adams, When in Rome (When in Rome, #1)

"I tell you what makes me madder than a hornet. When people tell other people how they should feel."

-Sarah Adams, When in Rome (When in Rome, #1)

"Care is reckless because it doesn’t come with the seat belt that selfishness offers. Care has so much to lose, and almost always ends in heartbreak."

-Sarah Adams, When in Rome (When in Rome, #1)

"Dry your tears and kick this gloomy attitude in the pants, Amelia!" I say out loud to myself because who else does a girl talk to when she's alone in the car in the middle of a mental breakdown?"

-Sarah Adams, When in Rome (When in Rome, #1)

Cover of The Off Limits Rule (It Happened in Nashville, #1) by Sarah       Adams

16. The Off Limits Rule (It Happened in Nashville, #1)

By: Sarah Adams

3.66

Format: 282 pages, Kindle Edition

Breaking a rule has never been so enticing. I have found rock bottom. It’s here, moving in with… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Adams's The Off Limits Rule (It Happened in Nashville, #1) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • humor
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
"Lucy, I want so much more with you...but I can't give you anything besides friendship right now."

-Sarah Adams, The Off Limits Rule (It Happened in Nashville, #1)

Cover of Funny Feelings by Tarah DeWitt

17. Funny Feelings

By: Tarah DeWitt

3.83

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Most anticipated by Book Riot, Her Campus, and San Diego Union Tribune ! When falling in love is… read more

Similar categories in Tarah DeWitt's Funny Feelings book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • humor
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Co-op by Tarah DeWitt

18. The Co-op

By: Tarah DeWitt

3.77

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

They say love and construction don't mix. By that logic, hate and construction may as well be con… read more

Similar categories in Tarah DeWitt's The Co-op book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of In the Weeds (Lovelight, #2) by B.K. Borison

19. In the Weeds (Lovelight, #2)

By: B.K. Borison

3.89

Format: 334 pages, Kindle Edition

Evelyn St. James isn’t the kind of woman you forget. Beckett Porter certainly hasn’t. One incred… read more

Similar categories in B.K. Borison's In the Weeds (Lovelight, #2) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Mixed Signals (Lovelight, #3) by B.K. Borison

20. Mixed Signals (Lovelight, #3)

By: B.K. Borison

4.04

Format: 335 pages, Kindle Edition

Layla Dupree has given up on love. She’s waded through all of the fish in the sea, each one more… read more

Similar categories in B.K. Borison's Mixed Signals (Lovelight, #3) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
"Has anyone ever fought for her the way she deserves?"

-B.K. Borison, Mixed Signals (Lovelight, #3)

"I tell you this because"—she scoops her spoon around the outer edge, eyes far away— "I tell you this because you are so like your grandfather." "I see things that aren't really there? " My stomach sw…"

-B.K. Borison, Mixed Signals (Lovelight, #3)

Cover of Business Casual (Lovelight, #4) by B.K. Borison

21. Business Casual (Lovelight, #4)

By: B.K. Borison

4.25

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Two opposites decide to test their chemistry with one steamy night together. But will once be enoug… read more

Similar categories in B.K. Borison's Business Casual (Lovelight, #4) book and Lynn Painter's Accidentally Amy

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook

21 must-read fiction books like Accidentally Amy by Lynn Painter

Transform Your Habits

Next of Kin (Next, #1)

Hannah Bonam-Young

3.80

Transform Your Habits

Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3)

Abby Jimenez

4.40

Transform Your Habits

Fangirl Down (Big Shots, #1)

Tessa Bailey

3.90

Transform Your Habits

The Paradise Problem

Christina Lauren

4.14

View all the books

20 must-read fiction books like The Long Game (The Long Game, #1) by Elena Armas

Transform Your Habits

Bride

Ali Hazelwood

4.04

Transform Your Habits

Funny Story

Emily Henry

4.27

Transform Your Habits

The Au Pair Affair (Big Shots, #2)

Tessa Bailey

3.71

Transform Your Habits

Just for the Summer (Part of Your World, #3)

Abby Jimenez

4.40

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.