21 Top dark books like Pen Pal by J.T. Geissinger

Cover of Pen Pal by J.T. Geissinger

Pen Pal

By: J.T. Geissinger

4.19

Format: 320 pages, Kindle Edition

The #1 international and Amazon Charts bestselling novel The first letter arrived the day my hus…

"When someone dies, you start counting all the ways you failed them."

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

"When someone dies, you start counting all the ways you failed them."

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

"Fucking hell, you’re sweet. You’re so goddamn sweet, I just want to sink my teeth into every inch of you."

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

"Fucking hell, you’re sweet. You’re so goddamn sweet, I just want to sink my teeth into every inch of you."

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

If you liked the dark plot in Pen Pal by J.T. Geissinger , here is a list of 21 books like this:

Cover of Older by Jennifer Hartmann

1. Older

By: Jennifer Hartmann

4.13

Format: 436 pages, Kindle Edition

Before he discovered my age, he uncovered my heart. Bruised and abused, and victim to a loveless… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Hartmann's Older book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of Praise (Salacious Players Club, #1) by Sara Cate

2. Praise (Salacious Players Club, #1)

By: Sara Cate

4.11

Format: 341 pages, Paperback

He calls me perfect. His flawless pet. His good girl. Broken down and wounded by my emotiona… read more

Similar categories in Sara Cate's Praise (Salacious Players Club, #1) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Butcher & Blackbird (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #1) by Brynne Weaver

3. Butcher & Blackbird (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #1)

By: Brynne Weaver

4.09

Format: 360 pages, Paperback

Every serial killer needs a friend. Every game must have a winner. When a chance encounter sp… read more

Similar categories in Brynne Weaver's Butcher & Blackbird (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #1) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • thriller
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Where's Molly by H.D. Carlton

4. Where's Molly

By: H.D. Carlton

4.20

Format: 243 pages, Kindle Edition

A spinoff of the Cat & Mouse Duet... “Molly Devereaux has been missing for more than two weeks, … read more

Similar categories in H.D. Carlton's Where's Molly book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • thriller
  • audiobook
Cover of Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5) by Shantel Tessier

5. Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5)

By: Shantel Tessier

4.31

Format: 628 pages, Kindle Edition

A PUPPET The men in the secret society known as the Lords think they rule the world. And in a way… read more

Similar categories in Shantel Tessier's Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • suspense
  • contemporary
"What is it?"

-Shantel Tessier, Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5)

"It’s my fault. I’m definitely one of those parents who takes a hundred percent responsibility for the monster I created."

-Shantel Tessier, Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5)

"I’ve been a sucker for that smile since the moment I held her. It’s amazing how cute and evil something can be at the same time."

-Shantel Tessier, Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5)

"She’ll survive. But I can’t promise you my love won’t be what kills us both. The Lords have taught me to fight until death to get what I want. I’ll do the same for her."

-Shantel Tessier, Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5)

Cover of The Sacrifice (L.O.R.D.S., #3) by Shantel Tessier

6. The Sacrifice (L.O.R.D.S., #3)

By: Shantel Tessier

4.31

Format: 644 pages, Kindle Edition

HIS LADY A Lord is to marry after he graduates from Barrington University, an elite college for … read more

Similar categories in Shantel Tessier's The Sacrifice (L.O.R.D.S., #3) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • audiobook
Cover of The Sinner (L.O.R.D.S., #2) by Shantel Tessier

7. The Sinner (L.O.R.D.S., #2)

By: Shantel Tessier

4.04

Format: 640 pages, None

An all-new dark standalone romance from author, Shantel Tessier. LITTLE DEMON I was raised in… read more

Similar categories in Shantel Tessier's The Sinner (L.O.R.D.S., #2) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of The Ritual (L.O.R.D.S., #1) by Shantel Tessier

8. The Ritual (L.O.R.D.S., #1)

By: Shantel Tessier

4.06

Format: 606 pages, Kindle Edition

THE CHOSEN ONE I vow. You vow. We vow. Barrington University is home of the Lords, a secret s… read more

Similar categories in Shantel Tessier's The Ritual (L.O.R.D.S., #1) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
"Fuck, I love you,"

-Shantel Tessier, The Ritual (L.O.R.D.S., #1)

"I vow. You vow. We vow."

-Shantel Tessier, The Ritual (L.O.R.D.S., #1)

"Desperation is never pretty."

-Shantel Tessier, The Ritual (L.O.R.D.S., #1)

"She's mine. It's just that simple."

-Shantel Tessier, The Ritual (L.O.R.D.S., #1)

Cover of Little Stranger (The Web of Silence Duet, #1) by Leigh Rivers

9. Little Stranger (The Web of Silence Duet, #1)

By: Leigh Rivers

3.81

Format: 207 pages, Kindle Edition

OWNING HER IS ALL HE EVER WANTED She betrayed him, and now he wants revenge against the sister w… read more

Similar categories in Leigh Rivers's Little Stranger (The Web of Silence Duet, #1) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of Still Beating by Jennifer Hartmann

10. Still Beating

By: Jennifer Hartmann

4.25

Format: 314 pages, Kindle Edition

WARNING: This book contains subject matter that may be sensitive for some readers. There is dark an… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Hartmann's Still Beating book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • thriller
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Hawke by Jescie Hall

11. Hawke

By: Jescie Hall

4.06

Format: 400 pages, None

Nicole never imagined anyone other than her seemingly perfect boyfriend, Patrick, could grab her at… read more

Similar categories in Jescie Hall's Hawke book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Leather & Lark (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #2) by Brynne Weaver

12. Leather & Lark (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #2)

By: Brynne Weaver

4.03

Format: 416 pages, Paperback

Contract killer Lachlan Kane wants a quiet life working in his leather studio and forgetting all ab… read more

Similar categories in Brynne Weaver's Leather & Lark (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #2) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • thriller
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
"A snow globe,"

-Brynne Weaver, Leather & Lark (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #2)

"I’m more like a multiple deleter."

-Brynne Weaver, Leather & Lark (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #2)

"...being in love is not enoug. Choosing love is what it takes."

-Brynne Weaver, Leather & Lark (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #2)

"Just like nature, the prettiest things are often the most poisonous."

-Brynne Weaver, Leather & Lark (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #2)

Cover of That Sik Luv by Jescie Hall

13. That Sik Luv

By: Jescie Hall

4.02

Format: 496 pages, Kindle Edition

Fornication is a sin. As it reads, we should flee from sexual immorality. Every other sin a per… read more

Similar categories in Jescie Hall's That Sik Luv book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • thriller
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
"Love is beneath us."

-Jescie Hall, That Sik Luv

Cover of Toxic by Nicole Blanchard

14. Toxic

By: Nicole Blanchard

3.55

Format: 268 pages, Kindle Edition

My life has been a series of bad decisions. Marrying an abusive man was the first... but falling… read more

Similar categories in Nicole Blanchard's Toxic book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of The Perfect Fit by Sadie Kincaid

15. The Perfect Fit

By: Sadie Kincaid

4.14

Format: 420 pages, Kindle Edition

A Dark Why Choose Romance. One wannabe writer from Brooklyn. Three insanely hot billionaires. … read more

Similar categories in Sadie Kincaid's The Perfect Fit book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of Pen Pal by J.T. Geissinger

16. Pen Pal

By: J.T. Geissinger

4.19

Format: 320 pages, Kindle Edition

The #1 international and Amazon Charts bestselling novel The first letter arrived the day my hus… read more

Similar categories in J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • contemporary romance
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
"When someone dies, you start counting all the ways you failed them."

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

"Fucking hell, you’re sweet. You’re so goddamn sweet, I just want to sink my teeth into every inch of you."

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

"Grief has blown me apart, scattering my bones into a desert wasteland where they’ll bake in silence under a merciless sun for a thousand years."

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

"Whatever love asks of you must be given, no matter the price. And I’d gladly give what love asked of me a thousand times over. Even if I had to do it every day until the end of eternity, I’d slice op…"

-J.T. Geissinger, Pen Pal

Cover of Does It Hurt? by H.D. Carlton

17. Does It Hurt?

By: H.D. Carlton

3.92

Format: 432 pages, Kindle Edition

Who am I? I've forgotten the answer to that question long ago. Ever since I ran from that house… read more

Similar categories in H.D. Carlton's Does It Hurt? book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Sabotage (L.O.R.D.S., #4) by Shantel Tessier

18. Sabotage (L.O.R.D.S., #4)

By: Shantel Tessier

3.82

Format: 229 pages, None

COLTON Raylee Lexington Adams is my stepsister and the one woman in the world who can make my bloo… read more

Similar categories in Shantel Tessier's Sabotage (L.O.R.D.S., #4) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
"Raylee’s here."

-Shantel Tessier, Sabotage (L.O.R.D.S., #4)

"A whore like her will fuck anything,"

-Shantel Tessier, Sabotage (L.O.R.D.S., #4)

"Reaching out, he grips my chin. His fingers dig into my skin, forcing a whimper from my parted lips. Holding me in place, he lowers his face to mine. “I love it when you cry,"

-Shantel Tessier, Sabotage (L.O.R.D.S., #4)

"I love him, and he loves me. I never expected my love to match my hatred for him. I thought the game of who can destroy the other was what would us in. But love? That’s the deadliest kind of drug. I …"

-Shantel Tessier, Sabotage (L.O.R.D.S., #4)

Cover of Lights Out by Navessa Allen

19. Lights Out

By: Navessa Allen

4.31

Format: 454 pages, Kindle Edition

“I don’t need another kink.” That thought pops into my head whenever I pull up my favorite socia… read more

Similar categories in Navessa Allen's Lights Out book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • thriller
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
"I nearly kicked at the floor like a petulant child. But I don't wanna go to bed! I want to stay up late and get railed!"

-Navessa Allen, Lights Out

Cover of Five Brothers by Penelope Douglas

20. Five Brothers

By: Penelope Douglas

3.96

Format: 560 pages, Paperback

One woman learns the secrets of the five Jaeger brothers. On the other side of town, in the dar… read more

Similar categories in Penelope Douglas's Five Brothers book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Madness (L.O.R.D.S., #6) by Shantel Tessier

21. Madness (L.O.R.D.S., #6)

By: Shantel Tessier

4.68

Format: 818 pages, Kindle Edition

HIS SECRET A Lord takes what he wants. But like anything else, even he can get greedy and betray… read more

Similar categories in Shantel Tessier's Madness (L.O.R.D.S., #6) book and J.T. Geissinger's Pen Pal

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
"Hey, doll face…"

-Shantel Tessier, Madness (L.O.R.D.S., #6)

"I have syphilis,"

-Shantel Tessier, Madness (L.O.R.D.S., #6)

"Two inches to the left, and it would have severed your femoral artery."

-Shantel Tessier, Madness (L.O.R.D.S., #6)

"I was willing to give my life up for hers. Now she's giving me life. Nothing could be better."

-Shantel Tessier, Madness (L.O.R.D.S., #6)

21 Top contemporary books like Pen Pal by J.T. Geissinger

Transform Your Habits

Older

Jennifer Hartmann

4.13

Transform Your Habits

Praise (Salacious Players Club, #1)

Sara Cate

4.11

Transform Your Habits

Butcher & Blackbird (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #1)

Brynne Weaver

4.09

Transform Your Habits

Where's Molly

H.D. Carlton

4.20

View all the books

16 best-selling fiction books like The Sacrifice (L.O.R.D.S., #3) by Shantel Tessier

Transform Your Habits

God of War (Legacy of Gods, #6)

Rina Kent

4.11

Transform Your Habits

Satan's Affair

H.D. Carlton

3.71

Transform Your Habits

God of Malice (Legacy of Gods, #1)

Rina Kent

3.96

Transform Your Habits

God of Pain (Legacy of Gods #2)

Rina Kent

3.91

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.