11 must-read crime books like A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1) by Colette Clark

Cover of A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1) by Colette Clark

A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

By: Colette Clark

4.32

Format: 254 pages, Kindle Edition

A death in a locked room and a house full of suspects… New York, 1925 Penelope “Pen” Banks has …

If you liked the crime plot in A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1) by Colette Clark , here is a list of 11 books like this:

Cover of Murder in the Library (Lottie Sprigg Country House #1) by Martha  Bond

1. Murder in the Library (Lottie Sprigg Country House #1)

By: Martha Bond

4.35

Format: 234 pages, Kindle Edition

Murder mystery at the manor!After months of travel, former maid, Lottie Sprigg, returns to Fortescu… read more

Similar categories in Martha Bond's Murder in the Library (Lottie Sprigg Country House #1) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • crime
Cover of Murder at a Funeral (Kitty Worthington, #9) by Magda Alexander

2. Murder at a Funeral (Kitty Worthington, #9)

By: Magda Alexander

4.48

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

England. 1924 . With her wedding day to CDI Robert Crawford Sinclair mere weeks away, Kitty Worthin… read more

Similar categories in Magda Alexander's Murder at a Funeral (Kitty Worthington, #9) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery
  • historical mystery
Cover of A Killer at the Castle (Lady Ellen Investigates #2) by Kelly Mason

3. A Killer at the Castle (Lady Ellen Investigates #2)

By: Kelly Mason

4.40

Format: 196 pages, Kindle Edition

Can Lady Ellen of Ashcombe Hall finally savour a relaxing break at Millars Hotel? Not quite. Her pl… read more

Similar categories in Kelly Mason's A Killer at the Castle (Lady Ellen Investigates #2) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

Cover of Murder on the Golden Arrow (Kitty Worthington, #1) by Magda Alexander

4. Murder on the Golden Arrow (Kitty Worthington, #1)

By: Magda Alexander

4.28

Format: 271 pages, Kindle Edition

What’s a bright young woman to do when her brother becomes the main suspect in a murder? Why, solve… read more

Similar categories in Magda Alexander's Murder on the Golden Arrow (Kitty Worthington, #1) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of Murder at the Masked Ball (Kitty Worthington, #3) by Magda Alexander

5. Murder at the Masked Ball (Kitty Worthington, #3)

By: Magda Alexander

4.44

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

Amateur sleuth Kitty Worthington once more investigates when a noble lord plummets to his death, an… read more

Similar categories in Magda Alexander's Murder at the Masked Ball (Kitty Worthington, #3) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of Murder at Westminster (Kitty Worthington, #2) by Magda Alexander

6. Murder at Westminster (Kitty Worthington, #2)

By: Magda Alexander

4.35

Format: 325 pages, Kindle Edition

Amateur sleuth Kitty Worthington once more jumps into the fray to nab the wily murderer of a high-r… read more

Similar categories in Magda Alexander's Murder at Westminster (Kitty Worthington, #2) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of Trouble on a Country Lane (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries #4) by Isabella Bassett

7. Trouble on a Country Lane (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries #4)

By: Isabella Bassett

4.30

Format: 188 pages, Kindle Edition

Beautiful, rich and young, for Lady Caroline, life is an easy road trip full of adventure. But when… read more

Similar categories in Isabella Bassett's Trouble on a Country Lane (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries #4) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of A Body in the Villa (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #3) by Isabella Bassett

8. A Body in the Villa (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #3)

By: Isabella Bassett

4.12

Format: 190 pages, Kindle Edition

Switzerland, 1925 A rare bird is nesting in the lush summer meadows of the Swiss Alps, and the g… read more

Similar categories in Isabella Bassett's A Body in the Villa (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #3) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of Death in the Garden (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #2) by Isabella Bassett

9. Death in the Garden (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #2)

By: Isabella Bassett

4.15

Format: 267 pages, Kindle Edition

Lake Garda, Italy, 1925 Uncle Albert, in relentless pursuit of his hobby, is off to a secluded i… read more

Similar categories in Isabella Bassett's Death in the Garden (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #2) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of Murder at the Grand Hotel (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #1) by Isabella Bassett

10. Murder at the Grand Hotel (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #1)

By: Isabella Bassett

3.99

Format: 216 pages, Kindle Edition

The French Riviera, 1925 Disgraced society “it” girl, Lady Caroline, has been shipped off to the… read more

Similar categories in Isabella Bassett's Murder at the Grand Hotel (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #1) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of A Murder of Christmas Past (Kitty Worthington, #5) by Magda Alexander

11. A Murder of Christmas Past (Kitty Worthington, #5)

By: Magda Alexander

4.23

Format: 120 pages, Kindle Edition

A Christmas wedding in an English castle. Tree trimming, carol singing, figgy pudding. What could b… read more

Similar categories in Magda Alexander's A Murder of Christmas Past (Kitty Worthington, #5) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
Cover of A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1) by Colette Clark

12. A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

By: Colette Clark

4.32

Format: 254 pages, Kindle Edition

A death in a locked room and a house full of suspects… New York, 1925 Penelope “Pen” Banks has … read more

Similar categories in Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • crime
Cover of Murder at the Tower of London (Kitty Worthington, #4) by Magda Alexander

13. Murder at the Tower of London (Kitty Worthington, #4)

By: Magda Alexander

4.33

Format: 263 pages, Kindle Edition

After a royal prince is assassinated at the Tower of London, Kitty Worthington is asked to investig… read more

Similar categories in Magda Alexander's Murder at the Tower of London (Kitty Worthington, #4) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • historical mystery
Cover of A Matter of Dead Ends: A 1920s Historical Mystery in London (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries Book 7) by Isabella Bassett

14. A Matter of Dead Ends: A 1920s Historical Mystery in London (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries Book 7)

By: Isabella Bassett

4.33

Format: 240 pages, Kindle Edition

The gentle waft of sewers emanating from Uncle Albert is not the only thing troubling Lady Caroline… read more

Similar categories in Isabella Bassett's A Matter of Dead Ends: A 1920s Historical Mystery in London (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries Book 7) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

Cover of A Murder at Oxford (Kitty Worthington, #6) by Magda Alexander

15. A Murder at Oxford (Kitty Worthington, #6)

By: Magda Alexander

4.50

Format: 239 pages, Kindle Edition

A murdered young woman. Her fiancé blamed for the crime. Can Kitty catch the killer before her belo… read more

Similar categories in Magda Alexander's A Murder at Oxford (Kitty Worthington, #6) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery
  • historical mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Brighton Murders (Camille Divine #3) by Andrea Hicks

16. The Brighton Murders (Camille Divine #3)

By: Andrea Hicks

4.52

Format: 312 pages, Kindle Edition

The week before Christmas - Brighton 1922When Camille discovers that her estranged husband, Lord He… read more

Similar categories in Andrea Hicks's The Brighton Murders (Camille Divine #3) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery
  • historical
  • crime
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Murder on the Dance Floor (Camille Divine #2) by Andrea Hicks

17. Murder on the Dance Floor (Camille Divine #2)

By: Andrea Hicks

4.49

Format: 311 pages, Kindle Edition

London 1922. The Summer Ball is arranged. Camille Divine has received her invitation to Antonella T… read more

Similar categories in Andrea Hicks's Murder on the Dance Floor (Camille Divine #2) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Murder at Millars Hotel (Lady Ellen Investigates #1) by Kelly Mason

18. Murder at Millars Hotel (Lady Ellen Investigates #1)

By: Kelly Mason

4.31

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

While her house is under renovation following its extensive use during the First World War, Lady As… read more

Similar categories in Kelly Mason's Murder at Millars Hotel (Lady Ellen Investigates #1) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery
  • historical
  • crime
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Christmas Tree Murders (Camille Divine #1) by Andrea Hicks

19. The Christmas Tree Murders (Camille Divine #1)

By: Andrea Hicks

4.20

Format: 333 pages, Kindle Edition

The Christmas trees in Knightsbridge sparkle with festive joy, and there’s nothing more fun than Ch… read more

Similar categories in Andrea Hicks's The Christmas Tree Murders (Camille Divine #1) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • historical
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
Cover of The Edinburgh Murders: A compelling murder mystery set in the Jazz Age of the 1920s (The Camille Divine Murder Mysteries, #10) by Andrea Hicks

20. The Edinburgh Murders: A compelling murder mystery set in the Jazz Age of the 1920s (The Camille Divine Murder Mysteries, #10)

By: Andrea Hicks

4.44

Format: 295 pages, Kindle Edition

When Camille Divine inherits her late husband's estate, including a mysterious house in Edinburgh, … read more

Similar categories in Andrea Hicks's The Edinburgh Murders: A compelling murder mystery set in the Jazz Age of the 1920s (The Camille Divine Murder Mysteries, #10) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

Cover of Murder in Paris (Camille Divine, #5) by Andrea Hicks

21. Murder in Paris (Camille Divine, #5)

By: Andrea Hicks

4.49

Format: 298 pages, Kindle Edition

Summer 1923 - PARIS Camille decides it's time to make her promised visit to Paris to see her old f… read more

Similar categories in Andrea Hicks's Murder in Paris (Camille Divine, #5) book and Colette Clark's A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1)

  • mystery
  • historical

9 best-selling fiction books like A Murder in Long Island (Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries, #1) by Colette Clark

Transform Your Habits

Murder on the Golden Arrow (Kitty Worthington, #1)

Magda Alexander

4.28

Transform Your Habits

Murder at the Masked Ball (Kitty Worthington, #3)

Magda Alexander

4.44

Transform Your Habits

Murder at Westminster (Kitty Worthington, #2)

Magda Alexander

4.35

Transform Your Habits

Death in the Garden (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #2)

Isabella Bassett

4.15

View all the books

9 best-selling historical books like The Brighton Murders (Camille Divine #3) by Andrea Hicks

Transform Your Habits

A Mystery at Moor House (Lady Ellen Investigates #3)

Kelly Mason

4.34

Transform Your Habits

Trouble on a Country Lane (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries #4)

Isabella Bassett

4.30

Transform Your Habits

A Body in the Villa (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #3)

Isabella Bassett

4.12

Transform Your Habits

Death in the Garden (Lady Caroline Murder Mysteries, #2)

Isabella Bassett

4.15

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.