6 Best supernatural books like Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2 by Elizabeth Pantley

Cover of Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2 by Elizabeth Pantley

Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

By: Elizabeth Pantley

4.46

Format: 219 pages, Kindle Edition

When this club selects a book, magic happens. They become the main characters in the story when the…

If you liked the supernatural plot in Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2 by Elizabeth Pantley , here is a list of 6 books like this:

1. Ghostly Manners (Lorna Shadow #1)

By: K.E. O'Connor

5.00

Format: 400 pages,

What really happened to Beatrice Galbraith three years ago? Lorna Shadow, personal assistant to the… read more

Similar categories in K.E. O'Connor's Ghostly Manners (Lorna Shadow #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

Cover of Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11) by Amanda M. Lee

2. Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.59

Format: 288 pages, Kindle Edition

Winter has descended on Hawthorne Hollow like a chilly blanket, and all Scout Randall wants to do w… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • vampires
  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of The Librarian of the Haunted Library: A Supernatural Suspense Horror Comedy (Strangely Scary Funny Book 1) by Brian Yansky

3. The Librarian of the Haunted Library: A Supernatural Suspense Horror Comedy (Strangely Scary Funny Book 1)

By: Brian Yansky

3.88

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

Demons, Headless seductresses, Rip Van Winkle, witches, occasional visits from angels, a god or two… read more

Similar categories in Brian Yansky's The Librarian of the Haunted Library: A Supernatural Suspense Horror Comedy (Strangely Scary Funny Book 1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • magic
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • supernatural
  • fantasy
Cover of Dead Companions (Afterlife Issues #1) by A.W. Hartoin

4. Dead Companions (Afterlife Issues #1)

By: A.W. Hartoin

4.61

Format: 316 pages, Kindle Edition

A death. A divorce. A perfect house with a less than perfect past. Jess and Libby have been… read more

Similar categories in A.W. Hartoin's Dead Companions (Afterlife Issues #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Cookie Calamity (Cookie Corner Paranormal Cozy Mysteries, #1) by Cindy Stark

5. Cookie Calamity (Cookie Corner Paranormal Cozy Mysteries, #1)

By: Cindy Stark

4.49

Format: 172 pages, Kindle Edition

When Evie St. Claire learns she’s the heir to a long-lost aunt’s entire estate, she momentarily bel… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Stark's Cookie Calamity (Cookie Corner Paranormal Cozy Mysteries, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of Butter, Sugar, Magic (Baking Up a Magical Midlife #1) by Jessica  Rosenberg

6. Butter, Sugar, Magic (Baking Up a Magical Midlife #1)

By: Jessica Rosenberg

4.21

Format: 359 pages, Kindle Edition

Embracing a midlife transformation has never been more delicious. At best, she’s expecting a kit… read more

Similar categories in Jessica Rosenberg's Butter, Sugar, Magic (Baking Up a Magical Midlife #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of The Grim Reaper Gaffe (Charlie Rhodes, #15) by Amanda M. Lee

7. The Grim Reaper Gaffe (Charlie Rhodes, #15)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.73

Format: 313 pages, Kindle Edition

Charlie Rhodes has fought witches, ghosts, chupacabras, and killer clowns. Now she must face her… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's The Grim Reaper Gaffe (Charlie Rhodes, #15) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Witchy Awakening (Midlife Potions #1) by C.A. Phipps

8. Witchy Awakening (Midlife Potions #1)

By: C.A. Phipps

4.06

Format: 168 pages, Kindle Edition

When Jessica Lavender's mother passes away, she's thrown into chaos. Things get even more complica… read more

Similar categories in C.A. Phipps's Witchy Awakening (Midlife Potions #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of The Tea Shop Witch (The Tea Shop Witch #1) by Thora Bluestone

9. The Tea Shop Witch (The Tea Shop Witch #1)

By: Thora Bluestone

4.02

Format: 237 pages, Kindle Edition

A disappearing body. Hidden magical talents. An adorable mind-reading dog. And small-town secrets .… read more

Similar categories in Thora Bluestone's The Tea Shop Witch (The Tea Shop Witch #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Familiar Spirits (Twilight Hollow, #1) by Sara Christene

10. Familiar Spirits (Twilight Hollow, #1)

By: Sara Christene

4.27

Format: 128 pages, Kindle Edition

An inept witch, a cozy town, and an old dark magic. Welcome to Twilight Hollow, WA, a small fore… read more

Similar categories in Sara Christene's Familiar Spirits (Twilight Hollow, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • supernatural
  • fantasy
Cover of Once Upon a Witch (Crooked Windows Inn Cozy Witch Mysteries, #1) by Valia Lind

11. Once Upon a Witch (Crooked Windows Inn Cozy Witch Mysteries, #1)

By: Valia Lind

4.32

Format: 137 pages, Kindle Edition

One magical mishap and her world goes up in flames. Cassandra Duke had her whole life figured ou… read more

Similar categories in Valia Lind's Once Upon a Witch (Crooked Windows Inn Cozy Witch Mysteries, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2 by Elizabeth Pantley

12. Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

By: Elizabeth Pantley

4.46

Format: 219 pages, Kindle Edition

When this club selects a book, magic happens. They become the main characters in the story when the… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2 book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • suspense
  • vampires
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • supernatural
  • fantasy
  • books about books
Cover of The Golden Ghouls (Monsters of Jellyfish Beach #1) by Ward Parker

13. The Golden Ghouls (Monsters of Jellyfish Beach #1)

By: Ward Parker

4.27

Format: 264 pages, Kindle Edition

Taking the paranormal mystery from cozy to crazy. My name is Missy Mindle. I’m a witch in my forti… read more

Similar categories in Ward Parker's The Golden Ghouls (Monsters of Jellyfish Beach #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • supernatural
  • vampires
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of There's a New Witch in Town Christmas Edition (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery, #1-2) ) by Carolyn Ridder Aspenson

14. There's a New Witch in Town Christmas Edition (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery, #1-2) )

By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson

4.25

Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition

USA TODAY BESTSELLING AUTHOR Carolyn Ridder Aspenson’s Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery Series… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's There's a New Witch in Town Christmas Edition (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery, #1-2) ) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of Cables and Conjurers (Vampire Knitting Club, #15) by Nancy Warren

15. Cables and Conjurers (Vampire Knitting Club, #15)

By: Nancy Warren

4.49

Format: 220 pages, Kindle Edition

Mystery A Paranormal Puzzle Lucy Swift, witch and knitting shop owner, thought her biggest chal… read more

Similar categories in Nancy Warren's Cables and Conjurers (Vampire Knitting Club, #15) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Southern Bred and Dead (Southern Ghost Hunter Mysteries, #9) by Angie Fox

16. Southern Bred and Dead (Southern Ghost Hunter Mysteries, #9)

By: Angie Fox

4.53

Format: 320 pages, Kindle Edition

A haunted church. A ghastly death. Can Verity clear up the case before she’s buried way over her he… read more

Similar categories in Angie Fox's Southern Bred and Dead (Southern Ghost Hunter Mysteries, #9) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • supernatural
  • fantasy
Cover of Spells and Spaniels (Familiar Spirits #1) by Christine Pope

17. Spells and Spaniels (Familiar Spirits #1)

By: Christine Pope

4.35

Format: 316 pages, Kindle Edition

Something’s got a spaniel familiar’s tongue…and it isn’t a cat. Charity Hughes is the first witc… read more

Similar categories in Christine Pope's Spells and Spaniels (Familiar Spirits #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Once Wicked  (Teas and Temptations, #1) by Cindy Stark

18. Once Wicked (Teas and Temptations, #1)

By: Cindy Stark

4.27

Format: 159 pages, Kindle Edition

A witch in hiding.An innocent spell.Let the mayhem begin.Hazel Hardy knows she shouldn’t tempt fate… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Stark's Once Wicked (Teas and Temptations, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • supernatural
  • fantasy
Cover of Magic Hidden, Magic Found (Wyrd Words & Witchcraft #1; Baking Up a Magical Midlife) by Jessica  Rosenberg

19. Magic Hidden, Magic Found (Wyrd Words & Witchcraft #1; Baking Up a Magical Midlife)

By: Jessica Rosenberg

4.30

Format: 283 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s always been a bookworm, but when surprising magical powers emerge, will she find the courage … read more

Similar categories in Jessica Rosenberg's Magic Hidden, Magic Found (Wyrd Words & Witchcraft #1; Baking Up a Magical Midlife) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of Gingerbread and Deadly Dread (Murder in the Mix, #4) by Addison Moore

20. Gingerbread and Deadly Dread (Murder in the Mix, #4)

By: Addison Moore

4.31

Format: 204 pages, Kindle Edition

My name is Lottie Lemon and I see dead people. Okay, so I rarely see dead people, mostly I see furr… read more

Similar categories in Addison Moore's Gingerbread and Deadly Dread (Murder in the Mix, #4) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Don't Worry Be Witchy (The Witches of Holiday Hills #13) by Carolyn Ridder Aspenson

21. Don't Worry Be Witchy (The Witches of Holiday Hills #13)

By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson

4.46

Format: 152 pages, Kindle Edition

What do pumpkin spice lattes and a crystalball have in common? Murder. Welcome to Holiday Hills… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's Don't Worry Be Witchy (The Witches of Holiday Hills #13) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
Cover of Gossip Ghost (Undertown Paranormal Mysteries, #1) by Tabatha Gray

22. Gossip Ghost (Undertown Paranormal Mysteries, #1)

By: Tabatha Gray

4.32

Format: 216 pages, Kindle Edition

Emma Day does NOT believe in ghosts. She does NOT have mystic powers. And she does NOT chase killer… read more

Similar categories in Tabatha Gray's Gossip Ghost (Undertown Paranormal Mysteries, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • paranormal
Cover of The Body in the Bookstore (A Secret Bookcase Mystery #1) by Ellie Alexander

23. The Body in the Bookstore (A Secret Bookcase Mystery #1)

By: Ellie Alexander

4.09

Format: 274 pages, ebook

Behind the shelves of The Secret Bookcase, where the sun slants through the windows onto rows of cl… read more

Similar categories in Ellie Alexander's The Body in the Bookstore (A Secret Bookcase Mystery #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • books about books
Cover of Clawing at the Corral (Nightmare, Arizona #6) by Beth Dolgner

24. Clawing at the Corral (Nightmare, Arizona #6)

By: Beth Dolgner

4.69

Format: 214 pages, Kindle Edition

Horses, Homicide, and Hope in Nightmare, Arizona Olivia Kendrick has déjà vu. The star of Nightm… read more

Similar categories in Beth Dolgner's Clawing at the Corral (Nightmare, Arizona #6) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • paranormal
Cover of All She Wants To Do Is Witch (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery Series Book 15) by Carolyn Ridder Aspenson

25. All She Wants To Do Is Witch (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery Series Book 15)

By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson

4.53

Format: 178 pages, Kindle Edition

Welcome to Holiday Hills, a magical town where the tea is sweet, and magic is always on the menu. A… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's All She Wants To Do Is Witch (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery Series Book 15) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of The Witch Club (Scottish Witches Mysteries #1) by Felicity  Green

26. The Witch Club (Scottish Witches Mysteries #1)

By: Felicity Green

4.35

Format: 251 pages, Kindle Edition

A creepy inn. Missing men. When only her new employee believes her, can she foil a pagan plot befor… read more

Similar categories in Felicity Green's The Witch Club (Scottish Witches Mysteries #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • paranormal
Cover of As the Grimoire Pages Turn (Murder, She Witches #1) by Kat McGee

27. As the Grimoire Pages Turn (Murder, She Witches #1)

By: Kat McGee

4.13

Format: 245 pages, Kindle Edition

A serial memoirist. A tell-all witchy memoir. A body in the bookstore reading nook. In the cozy … read more

Similar categories in Kat McGee's As the Grimoire Pages Turn (Murder, She Witches #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Message in the Manuscript (The Inn at Holiday Bay, #28) by Kathi Daley

28. Message in the Manuscript (The Inn at Holiday Bay, #28)

By: Kathi Daley

4.57

Format: 160 pages, Kindle Edition

A heartwarming cozy mystery series about losing everything, taking a chance, and starting again. … read more

Similar categories in Kathi Daley's Message in the Manuscript (The Inn at Holiday Bay, #28) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Sister Thing (Cottage on Gooseberry Bay #16) by Kathi Daley

29. A Sister Thing (Cottage on Gooseberry Bay #16)

By: Kathi Daley

4.62

Format: 138 pages, Kindle Edition

USA Today Bestselling author Kathi Daley brings you a heartwarming mystery series about finding ans… read more

Similar categories in Kathi Daley's A Sister Thing (Cottage on Gooseberry Bay #16) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Once Upon a Harvest Moon (The Bookstore at Holiday Bay) by Kathi Daley

30. Once Upon a Harvest Moon (The Bookstore at Holiday Bay)

By: Kathi Daley

4.57

Format: 209 pages, Kindle Edition

When Lou Prescott bought the bookstore at Holiday Bay, she wanted it to be so much more than a quai… read more

Similar categories in Kathi Daley's Once Upon a Harvest Moon (The Bookstore at Holiday Bay) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
Cover of A Nose for Mischief (Riverbend K-9s #1) by K.T.   Lee

31. A Nose for Mischief (Riverbend K-9s #1)

By: K.T. Lee

4.32

Format: None pages, Audiobook

When materials engineer Zoey Butler lands her dream job at Future State Energy, she believes her re… read more

Similar categories in K.T. Lee's A Nose for Mischief (Riverbend K-9s #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction

18 Top fiction books like Vampires and Villains: Magical Mystery Book Club #2 by Elizabeth Pantley

Transform Your Habits

Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11)

Amanda M. Lee

4.59

Transform Your Habits

The Librarian of the Haunted Library: A Supernatural Suspense Horror Comedy (Strangely Scary Funny Book 1)

Brian Yansky

3.88

Transform Your Habits

Cookie Calamity (Cookie Corner Paranormal Cozy Mysteries, #1)

Cindy Stark

4.49

Transform Your Habits

Butter, Sugar, Magic (Baking Up a Magical Midlife #1)

Jessica Rosenberg

4.21

View all the books

15 Best fiction books like The Tea Shop Witch (The Tea Shop Witch #1) by Thora Bluestone

Transform Your Habits

Books & Bribes (A Book Story Cozy Mystery, #1)

Lucinda Race

3.99

Transform Your Habits

Witchy Awakening (Midlife Potions #1)

C.A. Phipps

4.06

Transform Your Habits

The Tea Shop Witch (The Tea Shop Witch #1)

Thora Bluestone

4.02

Transform Your Habits

Lifestyles of the Witch and Ageless (Season of the Witch #1)

Shéa MacLeod

4.33

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.