12 Top mystery books like Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow by Christina Henry

Cover of Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow by Christina Henry

Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

By: Christina Henry

3.72

Format: 302 pages, Paperback

Everyone in Sleepy Hollow knows about the Horseman, but no one really believes in him. Not even Ben…

If you liked the mystery plot in Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow by Christina Henry , here is a list of 12 books like this:

Cover of Krampus: The Yule Lord by Brom

1. Krampus: The Yule Lord

By: Brom

4.04

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

"Terrific. A wild ride....I loved it. It hooked me and I couldn't put it down." --Mike Mignola, cre… read more

Similar categories in Brom's Krampus: The Yule Lord book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • horror

2. Dark Harvest

By: Norman Partridge

4.02

Format: 982 pages,

Winner of the Bram Stoker Award and named one of the 100 Best Novels of 2006 by Publishers Weekly, … read more

Similar categories in Norman Partridge's Dark Harvest book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

Cover of Episode Thirteen by Craig DiLouie

3. Episode Thirteen

By: Craig DiLouie

3.53

Format: 437 pages, Paperback

From the macabre mind of Bram Stoker Award nominated author Craig DiLouie, Episode Thirteen is a he… read more

Similar categories in Craig DiLouie's Episode Thirteen book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of The Hollow Places by T. Kingfisher

4. The Hollow Places

By: T. Kingfisher

3.80

Format: 337 pages, Paperback

A young woman discovers a strange portal in her uncle’s house, leading to madness and terror in thi… read more

Similar categories in T. Kingfisher's The Hollow Places book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
"If there's a way into hell, someone will always find it."

-T. Kingfisher, The Hollow Places

"No one has zombie raccoons roaming around their museum. That would just be silly."

-T. Kingfisher, The Hollow Places

"We had passed close in space, but separated by far too much time to make a difference."

-T. Kingfisher, The Hollow Places

"You're from Florida. There's got to be more holes to hell in Florida than any other state."

-T. Kingfisher, The Hollow Places

Cover of Hide by Kiersten White

5. Hide

By: Kiersten White

3.33

Format: 240 pages, Hardcover

The challenge: spend a week hiding in an abandoned amusement park and don't get caught. The priz… read more

Similar categories in Kiersten White's Hide book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
"What a generation long before her summoned and paid for, and what subsequent generations decided to make others pay for. Trickle-down economics. They got the economy, and the blood trickled down the …"

-Kiersten White, Hide

"Mack looks back at the maze that housed a monster that fed in youth and hope and stalled dreams. That ground up vulnerable people so the ones in power could keep their power, could keep their safety,…"

-Kiersten White, Hide

"So now she's seen it. She [Mack] knows what's out there. It doesn't make any more sense than it did before, but at least she can move from horror, the fear of the unknown, and into terror, the fear o…"

-Kiersten White, Hide

"He doesn't love you," she said matter-of-factly. "He didn't love your mother, either, and I don't want you to spend your whole life waiting for something he can't give. Men like that, people are thin…"

-Kiersten White, Hide

Cover of What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1) by T. Kingfisher

6. What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1)

By: T. Kingfisher

3.89

Format: 165 pages, Hardcover

From the award-winning author of The Twisted Ones comes a gripping and atmospheric retelling of Edg… read more

Similar categories in T. Kingfisher's What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1) book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • gothic
  • retellings
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • horror
  • adult
  • fantasy
"You shouldn't joke about fairies."

-T. Kingfisher, What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1)

"The dead don’t walk. Except, sometimes, when they do."

-T. Kingfisher, What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1)

"Most of us go to the Devil without him having to personally oversee things."

-T. Kingfisher, What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1)

"I had a strong urge to step back from them, and an even stronger urge to poke them with a stick."

-T. Kingfisher, What Moves the Dead (Sworn Soldier, #1)

Cover of Diavola by Jennifer Marie Thorne

7. Diavola

By: Jennifer Marie Thorne

3.95

Format: 296 pages, Kindle Edition

Jennifer Thorne skewers all-too-familiar family dynamics in this sly, wickedly funny vacation-Gothi… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Marie Thorne's Diavola book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • gothic
  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of The September House by Carissa Orlando

8. The September House

By: Carissa Orlando

3.92

Format: 344 pages, Hardcover

A woman is determined to stay in her dream home even after it becomes a haunted nightmare in this c… read more

Similar categories in Carissa Orlando's The September House book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • adult
  • paranormal
"the stars shone in the sky, reminding me there were calm constants everywhere"

-Carissa Orlando, The September House

"Hal was familiar with anger. He preferred it. It was like a warm blanket to him. Something soft, and smelling of home"

-Carissa Orlando, The September House

Cover of A House with Good Bones by T. Kingfisher

9. A House with Good Bones

By: T. Kingfisher

3.69

Format: 247 pages, Hardcover

A haunting Southern Gothic from an award-winning master of suspense, A House With Good Bones explor… read more

Similar categories in T. Kingfisher's A House with Good Bones book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • gothic
  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
"Like many family dynamics, it didn't have to be healthy, it just had to work."

-T. Kingfisher, A House with Good Bones

"He's got an alibi. People with alibis in the first half of the show are always suspicious."

-T. Kingfisher, A House with Good Bones

"I could research it. I am a champion researcher. It's why they pay me the meager academic bucks."

-T. Kingfisher, A House with Good Bones

"I understood Grand Mae then, I think. I could not pity the adult she had become, but I could pity the girl she had been."

-T. Kingfisher, A House with Good Bones

Cover of This Wretched Valley by Jenny Kiefer

10. This Wretched Valley

By: Jenny Kiefer

3.33

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Four ambitious climbers hike into the Kentucky wilderness. Seven months later, three mangled bodies… read more

Similar categories in Jenny Kiefer's This Wretched Valley book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • adult
  • fantasy
Cover of Black Sheep by Rachel   Harrison

11. Black Sheep

By: Rachel Harrison

3.60

Format: 289 pages, Hardcover

A cynical twentysomething must confront her unconventional family’s dark secrets in this fiery, irr… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Harrison's Black Sheep book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • adult
  • fantasy
"How can anyone know when ruin wears the disguise of love?"

-Rachel Harrison, Black Sheep

"I hoped wherever she was, she was having a shitty time, had an itch in a place she couldn't scratch."

-Rachel Harrison, Black Sheep

Cover of Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery by Brom

12. Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery

By: Brom

4.29

Format: 305 pages, Hardcover

Set in Colonial New England, Slewfoot is a tale of magic and mystery, of triumph and terror as only… read more

Similar categories in Brom's Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • fantasy
  • historical fiction
  • adult
  • paranormal
"You will think me foolish. But I wanted to be a fairy queen, to run barefoot through the woods, to sing like a bird and fly through the trees." She smiled. "To be able to talk to the animals."

-Brom, Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery

"He stared up into the trees, watched them sway in the soft breeze, watched the sun drift slowly across the sky, hour after hour, until it began to sink from view, trying to let go, to let his mind dr…"

-Brom, Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery

"Buzzing filled his ears, and he watched several bumblebees bounce from flower to flower. He found their hum soothing, and there, at the moment, felt he could watch them forever. He drank in the scent…"

-Brom, Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery

Cover of The Salt Grows Heavy by Cassandra Khaw

13. The Salt Grows Heavy

By: Cassandra Khaw

3.59

Format: 106 pages, Hardcover

From USA Today bestselling author Cassandra Khaw comes The Salt Grows Heavy, a razor-sharp and bewi… read more

Similar categories in Cassandra Khaw's The Salt Grows Heavy book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • retellings
  • fiction
  • horror
  • adult
  • fantasy
"And you shall know her by the trail of dead"

-Cassandra Khaw, The Salt Grows Heavy

"There is nothing wrong with being a monster."

-Cassandra Khaw, The Salt Grows Heavy

"A thousand mythologies contributed to my conception."

-Cassandra Khaw, The Salt Grows Heavy

"The truth liberates; it cannot cripple or maul, cannot injure, not unless one declares themselves its apostate."

-Cassandra Khaw, The Salt Grows Heavy

Cover of The Spite House by Johnny Compton

14. The Spite House

By: Johnny Compton

3.53

Format: 261 pages, Hardcover

Eric Ross is on the run from a mysterious past with his two daughters in tow. Having left his wife,… read more

Similar categories in Johnny Compton's The Spite House book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • gothic
  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of All Hallows by Christopher Golden

15. All Hallows

By: Christopher Golden

3.55

Format: 325 pages, Hardcover

With the 80's nostalgia of Stranger Things, this horror drama from NYT bestselling author Christoph… read more

Similar categories in Christopher Golden's All Hallows book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • halloween
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • horror
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow by Christina Henry

16. Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

By: Christina Henry

3.72

Format: 302 pages, Paperback

Everyone in Sleepy Hollow knows about the Horseman, but no one really believes in him. Not even Ben… read more

Similar categories in Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • gothic
  • retellings
  • halloween
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • horror
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Cursed by Marie O'Regan

17. Cursed

By: Marie O'Regan

3.55

Format: 373 pages, Paperback

Twenty curses, old and new, from bestselling fantasy authors such as Neil Gaiman, Karen Joy Fowler,… read more

Similar categories in Marie O'Regan's Cursed book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • retellings
  • fiction
  • horror
  • adult
  • fantasy
Cover of Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman

18. Incidents Around the House

By: Josh Malerman

3.82

Format: 371 pages, Hardcover

A chilling horror novel about a haunting told from the perspective of a young girl whose troubled f… read more

Similar categories in Josh Malerman's Incidents Around the House book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Frau Holles Labyrinth by Stefanie Lasthaus

19. Frau Holles Labyrinth

By: Stefanie Lasthaus

3.16

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

Als Phila zum einundzwanzigsten Geburtstag ihrer jüngeren Schwester Millie nach Hause aufs Land fah… read more

Similar categories in Stefanie Lasthaus's Frau Holles Labyrinth book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • retellings
  • fantasy
Cover of Die Schneekönigin - Kristalle aus Eis und Blut by C.E. Bernard

20. Die Schneekönigin - Kristalle aus Eis und Blut

By: C.E. Bernard

3.98

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

Du liebst gruselige Neuerzählungen wie »Die Dunklen Chroniken«, die »Disney – Villains« und »Twiste… read more

Similar categories in C.E. Bernard's Die Schneekönigin - Kristalle aus Eis und Blut book and Christina Henry's Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow

  • fantasy

18 best-selling fiction books like Horseman: A Tale of Sleepy Hollow by Christina Henry

Transform Your Habits

Krampus: The Yule Lord

Brom

4.04

Transform Your Habits

Episode Thirteen

Craig DiLouie

3.53

Transform Your Habits

The Hollow Places

T. Kingfisher

3.80

Transform Your Habits

Hide

Kiersten White

3.33

View all the books

21 must-read fiction books like Cursed by Marie O'Regan

Transform Your Habits

Alice (The Chronicles of Alice, #1)

Christina Henry

3.84

Transform Your Habits

Kitty Saves the World (Kitty Norville, #14)

Carrie Vaughn

3.72

Transform Your Habits

Troll Bridge

Neil Gaiman

3.96

Transform Your Habits

Lost Boy: The True Story of Captain Hook

Christina Henry

4.04

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.