17 Top fiction books like Unorthodox Love by Heidi Shertok

Cover of Unorthodox Love by Heidi  Shertok

Unorthodox Love

By: Heidi Shertok

3.74

Format: None pages, Paperback

Perfect for fans of Ali Hazelwood and Sophie Kinsella, Heidi Shertok’s delightful debut about love …

If you liked the fiction plot in Unorthodox Love by Heidi Shertok , here is a list of 17 books like this:

Cover of Kissing Kosher by Jean Meltzer

1. Kissing Kosher

By: Jean Meltzer

3.84

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

Step 1: Get the secret recipe. Step 2: Don’t fall in love… Avital Cohen isn’t wearing underpants… read more

Similar categories in Jean Meltzer's Kissing Kosher book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Rent to Be by Sonia Hartl

2. Rent to Be

By: Sonia Hartl

3.57

Format: 285 pages, Kindle Edition

Isla Jane is living the millennial nightmare. She’s got a shiny new MBA and no way to pay for it, t… read more

Similar categories in Sonia Hartl's Rent to Be book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Uncomfortable Conversations with a Jew by Emmanuel Acho

3. Uncomfortable Conversations with a Jew

By: Emmanuel Acho

4.53

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

From two New York Times bestselling authors, a timely, disarmingly honest, and thought-provoking in… read more

Similar categories in Emmanuel Acho's Uncomfortable Conversations with a Jew book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • audiobook
  • adult
  • jewish
Cover of Eight Dates and Nights by Betsy Aldredge

4. Eight Dates and Nights

By: Betsy Aldredge

3.50

Format: 236 pages, Kindle Edition

Two teens with two very different ideas of how to spend Hanukkah learn to work together to save the… read more

Similar categories in Betsy Aldredge's Eight Dates and Nights book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • audiobook
Cover of Business or Pleasure by Rachel Lynn Solomon

5. Business or Pleasure

By: Rachel Lynn Solomon

3.76

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

Chandler Cohen has never felt more like the ghost in "ghostwriter" until she attends a signing for … read more

Similar categories in Rachel Lynn Solomon's Business or Pleasure book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Unorthodox Love by Heidi  Shertok

6. Unorthodox Love

By: Heidi Shertok

3.74

Format: None pages, Paperback

Perfect for fans of Ali Hazelwood and Sophie Kinsella, Heidi Shertok’s delightful debut about love … read more

Similar categories in Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • jewish
  • adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Mr. Perfect on Paper by Jean Meltzer

7. Mr. Perfect on Paper

By: Jean Meltzer

3.73

Format: 387 pages, Hardcover

From the author of The Matzah Ball comes a pitch-perfect romcom following a third-generation Jewish… read more

Similar categories in Jean Meltzer's Mr. Perfect on Paper book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
"You deserve someone who loves you, Daniel," Dara said. "You deserve someone who sets your heart on fire, and makes you excited to get out of bed each morning."

-Jean Meltzer, Mr. Perfect on Paper

"You deserve someone who loves you, Daniel," Dara said. "You deserve someone who sets your heart on fire, and makes you excitedn to get out of bed each morning."

-Jean Meltzer, Mr. Perfect on Paper

"But, what I learned from this journey, from finding my real-life Mr. Perfect Paper, is that love isn't something that can be quantified on a list. Love is messy. And terrifying. It shows up whwn you …"

-Jean Meltzer, Mr. Perfect on Paper

Cover of Keep This Off the Record by Arden Joy

8. Keep This Off the Record

By: Arden Joy

3.50

Format: 340 pages, Paperback

Abigail Meyer and Freya Jonsson can’t stand one another. But could their severe hatred be maskin… read more

Similar categories in Arden Joy's Keep This Off the Record book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Marry Me by Midnight (Once Upon the East End #1) by Felicia Grossman

9. Marry Me by Midnight (Once Upon the East End #1)

By: Felicia Grossman

3.58

Format: 378 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Author Felicia Grossman—whose “books are powerful and passionate and swoon-inducing!” (Eva Leigh, U… read more

Similar categories in Felicia Grossman's Marry Me by Midnight (Once Upon the East End #1) book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Marriage Box by Corie Adjmi

10. The Marriage Box

By: Corie Adjmi

3.66

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

Casey Cohen, a Middle Eastern Jew, is a sixteen-year-old in New Orleans in the 1970s when she start… read more

Similar categories in Corie Adjmi's The Marriage Box book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • contemporary
  • fiction
  • jewish
Cover of Next-Door Nemesis by Alexa  Martin

11. Next-Door Nemesis

By: Alexa Martin

3.59

Format: 367 pages, Kindle Edition

Two rival candidates for a homeowner’s association presidency are about to find out how dirty subur… read more

Similar categories in Alexa Martin's Next-Door Nemesis book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Piece of Cake by Mary Hollis Huddleston

12. Piece of Cake

By: Mary Hollis Huddleston

3.41

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

She’s only trying to save her job and her reputation. Claire Sommers grew up as a society girl dest… read more

Similar categories in Mary Hollis Huddleston's Piece of Cake book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
"The pièce de résistance was the aisle and spot where the couple would say their vows. The aisle itself was made of white plexiglass, and above it were draped lush, dimensional bouquets of white flowe…"

-Mary Hollis Huddleston, Piece of Cake

"Long wooden farm tables with turned legs that looked like they'd been collected over a hundred years were placed end to end and ran the entire length of the space. Tapered candles in glass sleeves we…"

-Mary Hollis Huddleston, Piece of Cake

"The home I grew up in was something you might expect to find in an F. Scott Fitzgerald novel. Domed ceilings with ornate moldings, inlaid marble floors, and more powder rooms than people. It was a sm…"

-Mary Hollis Huddleston, Piece of Cake

"We walked around the other side of the whitewashed barn structure, where the massive antique doors had been opened and adorned with large wreaths made entirely of baby's breath. Inside, every wooden …"

-Mary Hollis Huddleston, Piece of Cake

Cover of Someone Just Like You by Meredith Schorr

13. Someone Just Like You

By: Meredith Schorr

3.43

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

Two childhood rivals are forced to work together to plan their parents’ anniversary party in “this … read more

Similar categories in Meredith Schorr's Someone Just Like You book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of What You Do to Me by Rochelle B. Weinstein

14. What You Do to Me

By: Rochelle B. Weinstein

4.24

Format: 363 pages, Kindle Edition

From the bestselling author of This Is Not How It Ends comes a moving novel of two unfinished love … read more

Similar categories in Rochelle B. Weinstein's What You Do to Me book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
Cover of Till There Was You by Lindsay Hameroff

15. Till There Was You

By: Lindsay Hameroff

3.73

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Culinary student Lexi Berman, 24, has one goal: to make her late mother proud by becoming an execut… read more

Similar categories in Lindsay Hameroff's Till There Was You book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
Cover of Kissing Girls on Shabbat: A Memoir by Sara Glass

16. Kissing Girls on Shabbat: A Memoir

By: Sara Glass

4.38

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

A moving coming-of-age memoir in the vein of Unorthodox and Brazen , about one young woman’s desper… read more

Similar categories in Sara Glass's Kissing Girls on Shabbat: A Memoir book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • audiobook
  • jewish
Cover of Jackpot Summer by Elyssa Friedland

17. Jackpot Summer

By: Elyssa Friedland

3.57

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

After the Jacobson siblings win a life-changing fortune in the lottery, they assume their messy liv… read more

Similar categories in Elyssa Friedland's Jackpot Summer book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Rachel Experiment (From Sunset Park, With Love #2) by Lisa  Lin

18. The Rachel Experiment (From Sunset Park, With Love #2)

By: Lisa Lin

3.35

Format: 293 pages, Kindle Edition

Who knew that one night out would change everything? As a financial analyst, Rachel Bai is more … read more

Similar categories in Lisa Lin's The Rachel Experiment (From Sunset Park, With Love #2) book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of B'Nai Mitzvah Mistake (Last Girls Standing, #1) by Stacey Agdern

19. B'Nai Mitzvah Mistake (Last Girls Standing, #1)

By: Stacey Agdern

3.64

Format: 270 pages, Kindle Edition

Sharing isn’t caring when it comes to your big day. Judith Nachman loves working as a project ma… read more

Similar categories in Stacey Agdern's B'Nai Mitzvah Mistake (Last Girls Standing, #1) book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • contemporary
  • jewish
Cover of Magical Meet Cute by Jean Meltzer

20. Magical Meet Cute

By: Jean Meltzer

3.71

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

Is he the real deal…or did she truly summon a golem? Faye Kaplan used to be engaged. She also us… read more

Similar categories in Jean Meltzer's Magical Meet Cute book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • jewish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Late Night Love by Chayla Wolfberg

21. Late Night Love

By: Chayla Wolfberg

3.81

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

She has her dream job…but her cohost is a nightmare.Emily Beckerman has the dream job as a writer o… read more

Similar categories in Chayla Wolfberg's Late Night Love book and Heidi Shertok's Unorthodox Love

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • jewish
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance

18 best-selling contemporary books like Unorthodox Love by Heidi Shertok

Transform Your Habits

Kissing Kosher

Jean Meltzer

3.84

Transform Your Habits

Rent to Be

Sonia Hartl

3.57

Transform Your Habits

Eight Dates and Nights

Betsy Aldredge

3.50

Transform Your Habits

Business or Pleasure

Rachel Lynn Solomon

3.76

View all the books

28 must-read fiction books like What You Do to Me by Rochelle B. Weinstein

Transform Your Habits

Alternate Endings

Ali Rosen

3.79

Transform Your Habits

Blank

Zibby Owens

3.71

Transform Your Habits

Kissing Kosher

Jean Meltzer

3.84

Transform Your Habits

Find Me in California

Kerry Lonsdale

4.11

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.