10 Best cozy mystery books like Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) by Danielle Garrett

Cover of Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) by Danielle Garrett

Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

By: Danielle Garrett

4.06

Format: 60 pages, Kindle Edition

Shamrocks, rainbows, pots of gold, and … one irate leprechaun. Spring has sprung, and I’m finall…

If you liked the cozy mystery plot in Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) by Danielle Garrett , here is a list of 10 books like this:

Cover of Chilled to the Bone (Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill Witch #9) by Amanda M. Lee

1. Chilled to the Bone (Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill Witch #9)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.60

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

Stormy Morgan is flying high. She’s engaged. She’s used to her new routine. She’s even learning abo… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Chilled to the Bone (Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill Witch #9) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • witches
  • cozy mystery
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of The Withering Storm (The Withering Mysteries Book 3) by Amy Boyles

2. The Withering Storm (The Withering Mysteries Book 3)

By: Amy Boyles

4.54

Format: 192 pages, Kindle Edition

It’s all come down to this.Monster hunter Grim has been promised a cure for the disease that he’s i… read more

Similar categories in Amy Boyles's The Withering Storm (The Withering Mysteries Book 3) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Festive Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 4) by Jenna St. James

3. Festive Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 4)

By: Jenna St. James

4.70

Format: 149 pages, Kindle Edition

A Midlife Sea Witch Used to Working Alone A Handsome Demigod with a Penchant for Trouble An Islan… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Festive Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 4) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

Cover of Deadly Rains (Witch in the Woods, #25) by Jenna St. James

4. Deadly Rains (Witch in the Woods, #25)

By: Jenna St. James

4.69

Format: 154 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter And an Encha… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Rains (Witch in the Woods, #25) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

Cover of Deadly Seeds (Witch in the Woods, #24) by Jenna St. James

5. Deadly Seeds (Witch in the Woods, #24)

By: Jenna St. James

4.67

Format: 144 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter And an Encha… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Seeds (Witch in the Woods, #24) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) by Danielle Garrett

6. Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

By: Danielle Garrett

4.06

Format: 60 pages, Kindle Edition

Shamrocks, rainbows, pots of gold, and … one irate leprechaun. Spring has sprung, and I’m finall… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • romance
  • novella
  • cozy mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • witches
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of Assisted Murder (Kara Hilder, #9) by Jenna St. James

7. Assisted Murder (Kara Hilder, #9)

By: Jenna St. James

4.59

Format: 163 pages, Kindle Edition

A Valkyrie with Haphazard Magic A Fallen Angel Seeking Redemption An Unlikely Crime-Solving D… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Assisted Murder (Kara Hilder, #9) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Cursed Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 3) by Jenna St. James

8. Cursed Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 3)

By: Jenna St. James

4.68

Format: 141 pages, Kindle Edition

Midlife Sea Witch Used to Working Alone A Handsome Demigod with a Penchant for Trouble An Island … read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Cursed Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 3) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • paranormal
Cover of Deadly Arrow (Witch in the Woods, #23) by Jenna St. James

9. Deadly Arrow (Witch in the Woods, #23)

By: Jenna St. James

4.64

Format: 169 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter And an Encha… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Arrow (Witch in the Woods, #23) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • paranormal
Cover of Toxic Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 5) by Jenna St. James

10. Toxic Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 5)

By: Jenna St. James

4.67

Format: 142 pages, Kindle Edition

A Midlife Sea Witch Used to Working Alone A Handsome Demigod with a Penchant for Trouble An Islan… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Toxic Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 5) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

Cover of Deadly Mixer (Witch in the Woods, #21) by Jenna St. James

11. Deadly Mixer (Witch in the Woods, #21)

By: Jenna St. James

4.65

Format: 138 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter And an E… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Mixer (Witch in the Woods, #21) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of All Witches on Deck (Moonstone Bay #14) by Amanda M. Lee

12. All Witches on Deck (Moonstone Bay #14)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.66

Format: 280 pages, Kindle Edition

Hadley Hunter is the new mayor about town...and she's about of find trouble. She won't be alone for… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's All Witches on Deck (Moonstone Bay #14) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Witches Get Stitches (Witch on the Rocks, #8) by Lily Harper Hart

13. Witches Get Stitches (Witch on the Rocks, #8)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.64

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

Hali Waverly is in a holding pattern following hip surgery. She’s getting better, but she still has… read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Witches Get Stitches (Witch on the Rocks, #8) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Deadly Storm (Witch in the Woods, #22) by Jenna St. James

14. Deadly Storm (Witch in the Woods, #22)

By: Jenna St. James

4.65

Format: 151 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter And an Enchant… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Storm (Witch in the Woods, #22) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Closing Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 6) by Jenna St. James

15. Closing Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 6)

By: Jenna St. James

4.70

Format: 144 pages, Kindle Edition

Midlife Sea Witch Used to Working Alone A Handsome Demigod with a Penchant for Trouble An Island … read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Closing Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 6) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • paranormal
Cover of Crystal Cove Paranormal Cozy Mysteries: Books 1-6 (Cindy Stark: Paranormal Mystery Series Collections) by Cindy Stark

16. Crystal Cove Paranormal Cozy Mysteries: Books 1-6 (Cindy Stark: Paranormal Mystery Series Collections)

By: Cindy Stark

4.70

Format: 1089 pages, Kindle Edition

From Book A MURDER MOST MYSTIFYING...When Opal returns to the mystical shores of Crystal Cove, she … read more

Similar categories in Cindy Stark's Crystal Cove Paranormal Cozy Mysteries: Books 1-6 (Cindy Stark: Paranormal Mystery Series Collections) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

Cover of Sweet Mountain Witches Paranormal Cozy Mysteries: Books 1-9 (Cindy Stark: Paranormal Mystery Series Collections) by Cindy Stark

17. Sweet Mountain Witches Paranormal Cozy Mysteries: Books 1-9 (Cindy Stark: Paranormal Mystery Series Collections)

By: Cindy Stark

4.66

Format: 1436 pages, Kindle Edition

From Book She thinks she’s escaped her midlife crisis…When Daisy Summers turned forty, she thought … read more

Similar categories in Cindy Stark's Sweet Mountain Witches Paranormal Cozy Mysteries: Books 1-9 (Cindy Stark: Paranormal Mystery Series Collections) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

Cover of Freaky Ways (Mystic Caravan, #18) by Amanda M. Lee

18. Freaky Ways (Mystic Caravan, #18)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.69

Format: 312 pages, Kindle Edition

The honeymoon is over for Poet and Kade. After a blissful week off from the day-to-day grind of the… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Freaky Ways (Mystic Caravan, #18) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Taming of the Brew (Supernatural Speakeasy, #15) by Lily Harper Hart

19. Taming of the Brew (Supernatural Speakeasy, #15)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.70

Format: 239 pages, Kindle Edition

Life in the French Quarter is quiet…which is exactly how Ofeila Archer likes it. She’s making plans… read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Taming of the Brew (Supernatural Speakeasy, #15) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Deadly Tempo (Witch in the Woods, #26) by Jenna St. James

20. Deadly Tempo (Witch in the Woods, #26)

By: Jenna St. James

4.62

Format: 175 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter And an Encha… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Tempo (Witch in the Woods, #26) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Deadly Summer (Witch in the Woods, #27) by Jenna St. James

21. Deadly Summer (Witch in the Woods, #27)

By: Jenna St. James

4.69

Format: 154 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career... A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter... An… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Summer (Witch in the Woods, #27) book and Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

6 Top fantasy books like Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) by Danielle Garrett

Transform Your Habits

Chilled to the Bone (Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill Witch #9)

Amanda M. Lee

4.60

Transform Your Habits

The Withering Storm (The Withering Mysteries Book 3)

Amy Boyles

4.54

Transform Your Habits

Deadly Seeds (Witch in the Woods, #24)

Jenna St. James

4.67

Transform Your Habits

Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

Danielle Garrett

4.06

View all the books

10 must-read fantasy books like The Withering Storm (The Withering Mysteries Book 3) by Amy Boyles

Transform Your Habits

Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11)

Amanda M. Lee

4.59

Transform Your Habits

All Quiet On the Witchy Front (Wicked Witches of the Midwest #24)

Amanda M. Lee

4.70

Transform Your Habits

Hexcess Baggage (Supernatural Speakeasy, #14)

Lily Harper Hart

4.69

Transform Your Habits

Undead Urges (Luna Thorn #3)

Amanda M. Lee

4.70

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.