15 best-selling contemporary romance books like To Catch a Firefly by Emmy Sanders

Cover of To Catch a Firefly by Emmy Sanders

To Catch a Firefly

By: Emmy Sanders

4.46

Format: 313 pages, Kindle Edition

He was my beginning. And my never-ending. Ellis There’s a lot I’ve never told my best friend. T…

If you liked the contemporary romance plot in To Catch a Firefly by Emmy Sanders , here is a list of 15 books like this:

Cover of Just a Taste by Briar Prescott

1. Just a Taste

By: Briar Prescott

4.21

Format: 356 pages, Kindle Edition

Lake: So... I’m getting married. Just three minor details: my husband-to-be is technically also m… read more

Similar categories in Briar Prescott's Just a Taste book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Red Flags & Tuesdays (Weekday Weirdos) by Nordika Night

2. Red Flags & Tuesdays (Weekday Weirdos)

By: Nordika Night

4.35

Format: 308 pages, Kindle Edition

Waking up to his one-night stand trying to flee the scene, Reid sits back to enjoy the show. This b… read more

Similar categories in Nordika Night's Red Flags & Tuesdays (Weekday Weirdos) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • mental health
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
"It won't last...we're already over."

-Nordika Night, Red Flags & Tuesdays (Weekday Weirdos)

Cover of The Revenge Agenda (Accidental Love, #3) by Saxon James

3. The Revenge Agenda (Accidental Love, #3)

By: Saxon James

4.20

Format: 280 pages, Kindle Edition

Rush When I show up to surprise my boyfriend in a barely-there festive outfit, I’m expecting him… read more

Similar categories in Saxon James's The Revenge Agenda (Accidental Love, #3) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • mental health
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
Cover of Bromantic Puckboy (Puckboys, #6) by Eden Finley

4. Bromantic Puckboy (Puckboys, #6)

By: Eden Finley

4.22

Format: 274 pages, Kindle Edition

Bilson The idea of moving away from Seattle was a joke at first. I have too many failed relat… read more

Similar categories in Eden Finley's Bromantic Puckboy (Puckboys, #6) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of The Step Bet (Peach State Stepbros, #1) by Riley Hart

5. The Step Bet (Peach State Stepbros, #1)

By: Riley Hart

3.98

Format: 388 pages, Kindle Edition

TROY Sometimes I want to punch that smirk off Atlas McCallister’s pretty face. He’s cocky. A … read more

Similar categories in Riley Hart's The Step Bet (Peach State Stepbros, #1) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
Cover of Pretty Boy (The Boys of Apartment 13, #1) by Brianna Flores

6. Pretty Boy (The Boys of Apartment 13, #1)

By: Brianna Flores

4.09

Format: 395 pages, Kindle Edition

Pretty boy Liam Walker is unlucky in love… Liam My newest obsession is nothing like any of my… read more

Similar categories in Brianna Flores's Pretty Boy (The Boys of Apartment 13, #1) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
Cover of Possessive Park Avenue Prince (Park Avenue Princes #4) by Brooke Blaine

7. Possessive Park Avenue Prince (Park Avenue Princes #4)

By: Brooke Blaine

4.17

Format: 343 pages, Kindle Edition

Who are we? Like you even need to ask. We’re the seven richer-than-sin legacies causing debauchery … read more

Similar categories in Brooke Blaine's Possessive Park Avenue Prince (Park Avenue Princes #4) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
"Love me,"

-Brooke Blaine, Possessive Park Avenue Prince (Park Avenue Princes #4)

"Trust me,"

-Brooke Blaine, Possessive Park Avenue Prince (Park Avenue Princes #4)

Cover of To Catch a Firefly by Emmy Sanders

8. To Catch a Firefly

By: Emmy Sanders

4.46

Format: 313 pages, Kindle Edition

He was my beginning. And my never-ending. Ellis There’s a lot I’ve never told my best friend. T… read more

Similar categories in Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • mental health
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • disability
  • queer
Cover of On Guard (New York Gods, #1) by Andi Jaxon

9. On Guard (New York Gods, #1)

By: Andi Jaxon

3.88

Format: 380 pages, Kindle Edition

Selling my virginity wasn’t how I saw my first week of college going. But after my parents cut m… read more

Similar categories in Andi Jaxon's On Guard (New York Gods, #1) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of A Stealthy Situation (Franklin U 2, #2) by Saxon James

10. A Stealthy Situation (Franklin U 2, #2)

By: Saxon James

4.02

Format: 293 pages, Kindle Edition

Harrison My life’s goal? Make plants fun! I’m gonna be fighting for flora when I’m older and … read more

Similar categories in Saxon James's A Stealthy Situation (Franklin U 2, #2) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • disability
  • queer
Cover of Want You Still by C.E. Ricci

11. Want You Still

By: C.E. Ricci

4.07

Format: 342 pages, Kindle Edition

The heart always wants what it can't have... Duty, honor, and sacrifice. Dedicating my life to t… read more

Similar categories in C.E. Ricci's Want You Still book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
Cover of The Caretaker (Infidelity #3) by C.P.  Harris

12. The Caretaker (Infidelity #3)

By: C.P. Harris

4.50

Format: 268 pages, Kindle Edition

The only thing Noon Waters is sure of is his undying love for his wife. But when a devastating acci… read more

Similar categories in C.P. Harris's The Caretaker (Infidelity #3) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • mental health
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Hateful Love (King of Aces #1) by T. Ashleigh

13. Hateful Love (King of Aces #1)

By: T. Ashleigh

4.06

Format: 418 pages, Kindle Edition

Silas: I'm tired of feeling trapped in my life. It’s just a never-ending cycle of trying to survi… read more

Similar categories in T. Ashleigh's Hateful Love (King of Aces #1) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
Cover of Exiled by Jessie  Walker

14. Exiled

By: Jessie Walker

4.41

Format: 578 pages, Paperback

"Close your eyes. I'll close mine too." Growing up, I was the problem child teachers didn’t kno… read more

Similar categories in Jessie Walker's Exiled book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • mental health
  • contemporary
  • disability
  • queer
Cover of Stupid Dirty (Possum Hollow, #1) by Erin  Russell

15. Stupid Dirty (Possum Hollow, #1)

By: Erin Russell

4.09

Format: 335 pages, Kindle Edition

CADE I always thought of Silas Rush as my biggest rival on the track and a stuck-up loner off it… read more

Similar categories in Erin Russell's Stupid Dirty (Possum Hollow, #1) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • mental health
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of The Hookup Mix-up (Franklin U 2, #1) by Riley Hart

16. The Hookup Mix-up (Franklin U 2, #1)

By: Riley Hart

4.11

Format: 243 pages, Kindle Edition

Perry I moved to San Luco to get to know my brother, and so far, it’s been great. Working as a bar… read more

Similar categories in Riley Hart's The Hookup Mix-up (Franklin U 2, #1) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
Cover of Suddenly You (Our Exception, #2) by Cora  Rose

17. Suddenly You (Our Exception, #2)

By: Cora Rose

4.25

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

We’ve all heard the saying, "What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas."God help me, if only that were t… read more

Similar categories in Cora Rose's Suddenly You (Our Exception, #2) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
Cover of Except You (Our Exception, #1) by Cora  Rose

18. Except You (Our Exception, #1)

By: Cora Rose

4.23

Format: 294 pages, Kindle Edition

A straight man walks into a gay bar searching for meaning…It sounds like the start of a lousy joke.… read more

Similar categories in Cora Rose's Except You (Our Exception, #1) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
Cover of Off Sides (Darby U Hockey Boys, #3) by Andi Jaxon

19. Off Sides (Darby U Hockey Boys, #3)

By: Andi Jaxon

4.04

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

The captain of the hockey team has a lot of responsibilities but when it’s just us, all he wants is… read more

Similar categories in Andi Jaxon's Off Sides (Darby U Hockey Boys, #3) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • contemporary
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
Cover of The Tragedy of Felix and Jake by J.  Daniels

20. The Tragedy of Felix and Jake

By: J. Daniels

4.32

Format: 431 pages, Kindle Edition

They say the best way to get over someone is to get under someone else. They say the best way to … read more

Similar categories in J. Daniels's The Tragedy of Felix and Jake book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • mental health
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer
"How can something so wonderful hurt like this?"

-J. Daniels, The Tragedy of Felix and Jake

"You make me feel better than any drug I’ve ever taken."

-J. Daniels, The Tragedy of Felix and Jake

"I’d drive six hours one way just to spend an hour with you."

-J. Daniels, The Tragedy of Felix and Jake

"What do you get the person you love when you’ve already given them your heart?"

-J. Daniels, The Tragedy of Felix and Jake

Cover of Burning the Midnight Oil (Copper Lake #3) by Ashley      James

21. Burning the Midnight Oil (Copper Lake #3)

By: Ashley James

4.07

Format: 350 pages, Kindle Edition

Rule number one: Don’t fall for my brother in law. It should be easy, right? Wrong. When I… read more

Similar categories in Ashley James's Burning the Midnight Oil (Copper Lake #3) book and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • queer

21 best-selling contemporary books like To Catch a Firefly by Emmy Sanders

Transform Your Habits

Just a Taste

Briar Prescott

4.21

Transform Your Habits

Red Flags & Tuesdays (Weekday Weirdos)

Nordika Night

4.35

Transform Your Habits

The Revenge Agenda (Accidental Love, #3)

Saxon James

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Bromantic Puckboy (Puckboys, #6)

Eden Finley

4.22

View all the books

21 Best contemporary books like The Hookup Mix-up (Franklin U 2, #1) by Riley Hart

Transform Your Habits

The Revenge Agenda (Accidental Love, #3)

Saxon James

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Bromantic Puckboy (Puckboys, #6)

Eden Finley

4.22

Transform Your Habits

Teach Me (Extracurricular Activities, #4)

Neve Wilder

4.00

Transform Your Habits

Dad Next Door (Crimson Club # 5)

Willow Dixon

3.97

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.