9 Best magic books like Sinner's Isle by Angela Montoya

Cover of Sinner's Isle by Angela Montoya

Sinner's Isle

By: Angela Montoya

3.91

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

A spellbinding romantic fantasy about a powerful witch who will do anything to escape the remote is…

If you liked the magic plot in Sinner's Isle by Angela Montoya , here is a list of 9 books like this:

Cover of The Poisons We Drink by Bethany Baptiste

1. The Poisons We Drink

By: Bethany Baptiste

3.75

Format: 480 pages, Hardcover

In a country divided between humans and witchers, Venus Stoneheart hustles as a brewer making illeg… read more

Similar categories in Bethany Baptiste's The Poisons We Drink book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • young adult
  • young adult fantasy
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Hearts That Cut (Threads That Bind, #2) by Kika Hatzopoulou

2. Hearts That Cut (Threads That Bind, #2)

By: Kika Hatzopoulou

4.02

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

In this heart-pounding, much-anticipated sequel to Threads That Bind , Io will face threats even mo… read more

Similar categories in Kika Hatzopoulou's Hearts That Cut (Threads That Bind, #2) book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • magic
  • young adult
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of A Fragile Enchantment by Allison Saft

3. A Fragile Enchantment

By: Allison Saft

3.53

Format: 373 pages, Hardcover

In this romantic fantasy of manners from New York Times bestselling author Allison Saft, a magical … read more

Similar categories in Allison Saft's A Fragile Enchantment book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • young adult
  • fantasy romance
  • romantasy
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
"You're like a pint-sized hurricane of earnestness and good cheer."

-Allison Saft, A Fragile Enchantment

"it's not meaningful to kill yourself little by little to make people happy!"

-Allison Saft, A Fragile Enchantment

Cover of Dragonfruit by Makiia Lucier

4. Dragonfruit

By: Makiia Lucier

3.89

Format: 356 pages, Hardcover

From acclaimed author Makiia Lucier, a dazzling, romantic fantasy inspired by Pacific Island mythol… read more

Similar categories in Makiia Lucier's Dragonfruit book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • magic
  • young adult
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
"Sam was quiet. Sometimes it was hard to look at her"

-Makiia Lucier, Dragonfruit

"sam was quiet, sometimes it hurt to look at her and know at closely they had come to missing one another"

-Makiia Lucier, Dragonfruit

"May Taga find your spirit and guide you home to the sea beyond. In clear water where danger will never catch you. Among the coral and caves where the bounty is full. Alongside your ancestors and thei…"

-Makiia Lucier, Dragonfruit

Cover of Raiders of the Lost Heart by Jo Segura

5. Raiders of the Lost Heart

By: Jo Segura

3.44

Format: 357 pages, Paperback

Rival archaeologists must team up on a secret Aztec expedition, or it could leave their careers—and… read more

Similar categories in Jo Segura's Raiders of the Lost Heart book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • audiobook
Cover of These Deadly Prophecies by Andrea Tang

6. These Deadly Prophecies

By: Andrea Tang

3.43

Format: 256 pages, Hardcover

A teenage sorcerer’s apprentice must solve her boss’s murder in order to prove her innocence in thi… read more

Similar categories in Andrea Tang's These Deadly Prophecies book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • magic
  • young adult
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Sinner's Isle by Angela Montoya

7. Sinner's Isle

By: Angela Montoya

3.91

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

A spellbinding romantic fantasy about a powerful witch who will do anything to escape the remote is… read more

Similar categories in Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • pirates
  • magic
  • young adult
  • fantasy romance
  • romantasy
  • young adult fantasy
  • witches
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of The Dangerous Ones by Lauren Blackwood

8. The Dangerous Ones

By: Lauren Blackwood

3.43

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

A romantic historical fantasy from New York Times bestselling author Lauren Blackwood, set in the A… read more

Similar categories in Lauren Blackwood's The Dangerous Ones book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • young adult
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Where the Dark Stands Still by A.B. Poranek

9. Where the Dark Stands Still

By: A.B. Poranek

4.12

Format: 336 pages, ebook

Raised in a small village near the spirit-wood, Liska Radost knows that Magic is monstrous, and its… read more

Similar categories in A.B. Poranek's Where the Dark Stands Still book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • magic
  • young adult
  • fantasy romance
  • romantasy
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
"We kissed, you incorrigible antlered tradgedy!"

-A.B. Poranek, Where the Dark Stands Still

"His eyebrows tilt up, firelight reflecting in his eyes. "It was always to be my fate." "Fate," she scoffs. "What is fate but an excuse to surrender responsibility? No, Eliasz, we cannot think of that…"

-A.B. Poranek, Where the Dark Stands Still

"Please," she begs. "Surely there must be some spell—there must be something, anything. Please, Eliasz, please. Tell me how to save you." "Liska, Liseczka. Oj, lisku." He raises her hand to his lips, …"

-A.B. Poranek, Where the Dark Stands Still

Cover of The Fall of Whit Rivera by Crystal Maldonado

10. The Fall of Whit Rivera

By: Crystal Maldonado

4.09

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

Could you plan the Fall Formal with your (hot) nemesis? Whit Rivera is about to find out. Frenemie… read more

Similar categories in Crystal Maldonado's The Fall of Whit Rivera book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • young adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Your Blood, My Bones by Kelly Andrew

11. Your Blood, My Bones

By: Kelly Andrew

3.79

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

A seductively twisted romance about loyalty, fate, the lengths we go to hide the darkest parts of o… read more

Similar categories in Kelly Andrew's Your Blood, My Bones book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • magic
  • young adult
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
Cover of Twelfth Knight by Alexene Farol Follmuth

12. Twelfth Knight

By: Alexene Farol Follmuth

3.90

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

Reese's Book Club Summer YA Pick '24 "YA is a feeling. It's a warm summer day reading in the sun… read more

Similar categories in Alexene Farol Follmuth's Twelfth Knight book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • young adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Diablo's Curse by Gabe Cole Novoa

13. The Diablo's Curse

By: Gabe Cole Novoa

4.23

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

From the author of The Wicked Bargain comes a high-stakes race to defeat a curse designed to kill a… read more

Similar categories in Gabe Cole Novoa's The Diablo's Curse book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • young adult
  • audiobook
Cover of The Last Bloodcarver (The Last Bloodcarver #1) by Vanessa Le

14. The Last Bloodcarver (The Last Bloodcarver #1)

By: Vanessa Le

3.99

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

The tantalizing romance of These Violent Delights meets the mechanical wonders of Cinder in The Las… read more

Similar categories in Vanessa Le's The Last Bloodcarver (The Last Bloodcarver #1) book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • magic
  • young adult
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of Lore of the Wilds (Lore of the Wilds, #1) by Analeigh Sbrana

15. Lore of the Wilds (Lore of the Wilds, #1)

By: Analeigh Sbrana

3.35

Format: 339 pages, Hardcover

A stunning Romantasy debut about an enchanted library, two handsome Fae, and one human who brings t… read more

Similar categories in Analeigh Sbrana's Lore of the Wilds (Lore of the Wilds, #1) book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • magic
  • young adult
  • fantasy romance
  • romantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of The Darkness Within Us (The Shadows Between Us, #2) by Tricia Levenseller

16. The Darkness Within Us (The Shadows Between Us, #2)

By: Tricia Levenseller

4.01

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Chrysantha Stathos has won. By hiding her intelligence and ambition behind the mask of a beautif… read more

Similar categories in Tricia Levenseller's The Darkness Within Us (The Shadows Between Us, #2) book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • magic
  • young adult
  • fantasy romance
  • romantasy
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
"I know you have options." "And those options will be taken away the second I marry. I will be beholden to my husband." "But you will be wealthy." "Is that what you'd choose? Bondage over freedom for …"

-Tricia Levenseller, The Darkness Within Us (The Shadows Between Us, #2)

Cover of The Atlas of Us by Kristin Dwyer

17. The Atlas of Us

By: Kristin Dwyer

4.10

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Atlas James has lost her way. In a last-ditch effort to pull her life together, she’s working on… read more

Similar categories in Kristin Dwyer's The Atlas of Us book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • young adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Us in Ruins by Rachel   Moore

18. Us in Ruins

By: Rachel Moore

3.84

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

Margot is on the quest to uncover and reassemble an ancient—and cursed—vase, with the help of a boy… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Moore's Us in Ruins book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • young adult
  • fantasy romance
  • romantasy
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
Cover of The Quince Project by Jessica Parra

19. The Quince Project

By: Jessica Parra

3.80

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Castillo Torres, Student Body Association event chair and serial planner, could use a fairy godmoth… read more

Similar categories in Jessica Parra's The Quince Project book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • young adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Wisteria (Belladonna, #3) by Adalyn  Grace

20. Wisteria (Belladonna, #3)

By: Adalyn Grace

4.35

Format: 432 pages, Hardcover

#1 New York Times bestselling author Adalyn Grace delivers a sensational conclusion to the deathly… read more

Similar categories in Adalyn Grace's Wisteria (Belladonna, #3) book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • young adult
  • fantasy romance
  • romantasy
  • young adult fantasy
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
"Burn as brightly as the sun if you wish, Aris, but I will not look away."

-Adalyn Grace, Wisteria (Belladonna, #3)

Cover of To a Darker Shore by Leanne Schwartz

21. To a Darker Shore

By: Leanne Schwartz

4.07

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

A da Vinci-esque teen girl inventor on a Dante-esque journey through hell to save her best friend. … read more

Similar categories in Leanne Schwartz's To a Darker Shore book and Angela Montoya's Sinner's Isle

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • young adult fantasy
  • young adult
"She couldn’t help the hope that kindled painfully in her chest. Couldn’t help the steps she took in the wrong direction—nearer to him. Greater than any pull of gravity upon a flier, more than her dut…"

-Leanne Schwartz, To a Darker Shore

17 Best fantasy books like Sinner's Isle by Angela Montoya

Transform Your Habits

The Poisons We Drink

Bethany Baptiste

3.75

Transform Your Habits

Hearts That Cut (Threads That Bind, #2)

Kika Hatzopoulou

4.02

Transform Your Habits

A Fragile Enchantment

Allison Saft

3.53

Transform Your Habits

Dragonfruit

Makiia Lucier

3.89

View all the books

12 must-read young adult fantasy books like Us in Ruins by Rachel Moore

Transform Your Habits

The Mirror of Beasts (Silver in the Bone, #2)

Alexandra Bracken

4.26

Transform Your Habits

Beneath These Cursed Stars

Lexi Ryan

3.92

Transform Your Habits

The Monstrous Kind

Lydia Gregovic

3.98

Transform Your Habits

Us in Ruins

Rachel Moore

3.84

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.