20 must-read amish books like Anything but Plain by Suzanne Woods Fisher

Cover of Anything but Plain by Suzanne Woods Fisher

Anything but Plain

By: Suzanne Woods Fisher

4.38

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

It's not easy being the bishop's daughter, especially for Lydie Stoltzfus. She's not like other Ami…

If you liked the amish plot in Anything but Plain by Suzanne Woods Fisher , here is a list of 20 books like this:

Cover of Orchard by Lewis

1. Orchard

By: Lewis

4.38

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

"She realized there was peace right here in the midst of this heavenly sort of place, despite the u… read more

Similar categories in Lewis's Orchard book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Something Old, Something New by Amy Clipston

2. Something Old, Something New

By: Amy Clipston

3.89

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

Sometimes treasure can be found where you least expect it. In the decade since high school gradu… read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's Something Old, Something New book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of Once Upon a Buggy (The Amish of Apple Creek #2) by Shelley Shepard Gray

3. Once Upon a Buggy (The Amish of Apple Creek #2)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.30

Format: 272 pages, Paperback

New York Times bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray—one of the most beloved voices in inspiratio… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Once Upon a Buggy (The Amish of Apple Creek #2) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1) by Shelley Shepard Gray

4. Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.42

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

Combining the appeal of a small-town Amish setting and favorite romance tropes, New York Times best… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of An Amish Cinderella (The Amish of Apple Creek 3) by Shelley Shepard Gray

5. An Amish Cinderella (The Amish of Apple Creek 3)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.41

Format: 256 pages, Paperback

New York Times bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray—one of the most beloved voices in inspiratio… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's An Amish Cinderella (The Amish of Apple Creek 3) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of The Story of Love (The Amish Bookstore #2) by Beth Wiseman

6. The Story of Love (The Amish Bookstore #2)

By: Beth Wiseman

4.46

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

When Yvonne Wilson’s Amish friends, Jake and Eva Lantz, offer her an opportunity to run their books… read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's The Story of Love (The Amish Bookstore #2) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Anything but Plain by Suzanne Woods Fisher

7. Anything but Plain

By: Suzanne Woods Fisher

4.38

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

It's not easy being the bishop's daughter, especially for Lydie Stoltzfus. She's not like other Ami… read more

Similar categories in Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • health
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

8. Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.29

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

Friendship Letters Series — Doretta Schwartz has always enjoyed writing letters and feels her lette… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Her Heart's Desire (A Season in Pinecraft, #1) by Shelley Shepard Gray

9. Her Heart's Desire (A Season in Pinecraft, #1)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.26

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Mary Margaret Miller needs an escape from her small Amish community. She boards a bus, all alone, f… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Her Heart's Desire (A Season in Pinecraft, #1) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of Every Good Gift (Amish Blessings, #3) by Kelly Irvin

10. Every Good Gift (Amish Blessings, #3)

By: Kelly Irvin

4.64

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

During the most difficult season of her life, how could she know whether their meeting was a gift f… read more

Similar categories in Kelly Irvin's Every Good Gift (Amish Blessings, #3) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • fiction
  • amish
Cover of Her Only Wish (A Season in Pinecraft #2) by Shelley Shepard Gray

11. Her Only Wish (A Season in Pinecraft #2)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.35

Format: None pages, Paperback

Return to Pinecraft, Florida, for a Sweet Amish RomanceSheltered yet adventurous, Betsy Detweiler i… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Her Only Wish (A Season in Pinecraft #2) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Foundation of Love (An Amish Legacy #1) by Amy Clipston

12. Foundation of Love (An Amish Legacy #1)

By: Amy Clipston

4.43

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

They were “only friends” . . . but they wanted so much more. Crystal Glick is grateful to live w… read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's Foundation of Love (An Amish Legacy #1) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • adult fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of Building a Future (An Amish Legacy, #2) by Amy Clipston

13. Building a Future (An Amish Legacy, #2)

By: Amy Clipston

4.42

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

They both had different plans for their futures . . . until their hearts led them to each other. … read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's Building a Future (An Amish Legacy, #2) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of Her Secret Hope by Shelley Shepard Gray

14. Her Secret Hope

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.32

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Almost two years after Lilly Kurtz first traveled to Pinecraft, Florida, with friends, she's decide… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Her Secret Hope book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Amish Quiltmaker's Unconventional Niece (The Amish Quiltmaker #3) by Jennifer Beckstrand

15. The Amish Quiltmaker's Unconventional Niece (The Amish Quiltmaker #3)

By: Jennifer Beckstrand

4.45

Format: 274 pages, Kindle Edition

Resourceful Colorado Amish quiltmaker Esther Kiem has her hands full with husband, home, and a baby… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Beckstrand's The Amish Quiltmaker's Unconventional Niece (The Amish Quiltmaker #3) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • fiction
  • amish
Cover of The Amish Matchmakers (Amish Inn) by Beth Wiseman

16. The Amish Matchmakers (Amish Inn)

By: Beth Wiseman

4.36

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

This Amish matchmaker is an expert at finding love for others, but will she find it for herself? Wi… read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's The Amish Matchmakers (Amish Inn) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Hopefully Ever After (The Amish Bookstore #3) by Beth Wiseman

17. Hopefully Ever After (The Amish Bookstore #3)

By: Beth Wiseman

4.48

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

To become who they’re meant to be, Eden and Samuel must find the courage to defy expectations. … read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's Hopefully Ever After (The Amish Bookstore #3) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Breaking New Ground (An Amish Legacy #3) by Amy Clipston

18. Breaking New Ground (An Amish Legacy #3)

By: Amy Clipston

4.44

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

Korey Bontrager and Savannah Zook are just pretending to date—but could their feelings turn into so… read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's Breaking New Ground (An Amish Legacy #3) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Christmas at the Amish Market by Shelley  Shepard Gray

19. Christmas at the Amish Market

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.14

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

Hallmark and bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray present a Christmas Amish romance with lots of… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Christmas at the Amish Market book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of The Courtship Plan (Amish of Marigold #1) by Kathleen Fuller

20. The Courtship Plan (Amish of Marigold #1)

By: Kathleen Fuller

4.30

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Finding a husband is serious business. And serious business requires serious planning. Charity R… read more

Similar categories in Kathleen Fuller's The Courtship Plan (Amish of Marigold #1) book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of Yesterday's Gone by Cindy Woodsmall

21. Yesterday's Gone

By: Cindy Woodsmall

4.19

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

Eliza holds a secret that can rewrite the past. Eliza Bontrager and Jesse Ebersol have fallen in l… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Woodsmall's Yesterday's Gone book and Suzanne Woods Fisher's Anything but Plain

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary

21 must-read fiction books like Anything but Plain by Suzanne Woods Fisher

Transform Your Habits

Orchard

Lewis

4.38

Transform Your Habits

Something Old, Something New

Amy Clipston

3.89

Transform Your Habits

Once Upon a Buggy (The Amish of Apple Creek #2)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.30

Transform Your Habits

Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.42

View all the books

18 Best fiction books like Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

Transform Your Habits

Orchard

Lewis

4.38

Transform Your Habits

The Heirloom

Beverly Lewis

4.37

Transform Your Habits

Once Upon a Buggy (The Amish of Apple Creek #2)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.30

Transform Your Habits

Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.42

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.